The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website


Moment In Time: Genesis' The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway Revisited
Nick Reed , November 14th, 2014 13:58

Nick Reed returns to Genesis' hefty 1974 double album opus, and finds, in-between the near-incomprehensible narrative and patchy second disc, a record that offers many fine moments and stakes a good claim to being the pinnacle of prog excess

Add your comment »

You would be hard-pressed to find an album with more to unpack than this one. With 40 years of hindsight, the canon of classic prog has been pretty well established. Us prog types tend to list and grade more than any other, but the same albums and bands come up time and time again. Then you have The Lamb, easily one of the most important and infamous prog albums of them all, but it feels like nobody has quite figured it out yet. 

Then again, Genesis in those days were some odd species of duck. Prog singers were often about function; sure, you've got the Peter Hammills who can really belt it out, but for the most part they were fine so long as they could hit all the notes and harmonise. Lyrics, sure, they were important too, but you were never really required to analyse them; Jon Anderson's were a fun mix of hippie profundity and nonsense, and if that bothered you, it just wasn't your genre.

Genesis, on the other hand, had a frontman you couldn't ignore; in Peter Gabriel, you had a guy who wore costumes on stage, told stories between songs, and would lapse into different voices on a whim. Gabriel's lyrics were usually strange, disturbed tales - maybe you can brush off a ridiculous Anderson lyric like "shining, flying, purple wolfhound, show me where you are", but Gabriel yelling "TOUCH ME NOW! NOW! NOW!" in his old man voice is something else entirely. Gabriel's presence (and the band's lack of a real soloist) was so dominant that it almost obscured the fact that there was a wealth of talent standing behind him.

The early 70s were a particularly fertile time for progressive rock - between 1971 and 1972 you had Fragile, Close To The Edge, Pawn Hearts, Tago Mago, Thick As A Brick, 666 and Octopus, among many others. Genesis had done a couple of classic albums themselves in that period. This was a time when progressive rock was still progressive - bands felt the need to up the stakes and take big leaps every time out, hence things went nuts in the following years. Yes infamously released ten songs spread over eight sides of music between 1972 and 1974 (to say nothing of their triple LP live set); ELP's Brain Salad Surgery had a piece so long it didn't even fit on one side of the album (to say nothing of their live triple LP).

And this was the world Genesis found themselves in. Sure, they'd done a side-long track already, and their previous LP, Selling England By The Pound, was about as perfect as prog rock albums came. But in 1974 it was go big or go home. 

So, we were given The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway. A double LP. It is progressive rock incarnate: overblown, mostly incoherent, and the type that takes many, many listens to unravel. It has transcendent, 'How did they do that?' moments and stretches of 'Why are they still doing this?' Tony Banks plays seven different types of keyboard on it (including the almighty Mellotron), Gabriel is credited with "experiments with foreign sounds", and Brian Eno gets a small credit for "enossification"; you never go for very long without the band trying something bizarre.

The recording process was filled with drama; though Gabriel conceived of the album's story and structure, he spent much of the time dealing with family issues and pursuing a career as a screenwriter. This left Tony Banks, Phil Collins and Mike Rutherford to write all the music. (I guess they left Steve Hackett behind at a mall in Hampshire or something.) As you may expect from a band that was touring extensively and releasing albums at a yearly pace, there isn't quite two LP's worth of material in them. A lot of bands in this situation would fill time with solos or long instrumental jams, but Genesis really aren't that type of band, so they dig deep.

One tune devolves into an avant-garde noise collage ('The Waiting Room'), two are adapted from unused songs dating back to the band's early days ('Lilywhite Lilith', 'Anyway'), and the band comes up with just enough ambient bits and linking interludes to fill 94 minutes' worth of space with music. 

Of course, when reduced to its best material, The Lamb is superb. The album opens with Banks playing a frantic, almost romantic piano figure that's too fast to be pretty; instead it almost feels oppressive. The resulting song is a pure shot of heavy-hitting prog theatre; Gabriel cycles through several different voices ("Don't look at me, I'm not your kind; I'm Rael!", the first of many spine-tingling moments), Rutherford overdrives the bass while Collins blows through the scenery.

A year or two earlier, the band might've extended the quiet part in the middle, but now these guys had work to do; 'The Lamb...' is one of the few prog epics that got radio play. You couldn't say that for anything else from this album except perhaps 'The Carpet Crawlers', though that one is almost unbearably creepy. Maybe 'Counting Out Time'? It's certainly catchy enough, but it also features lyrics about trying (and failing) to find a girl's hot zones, so that one's out. The first disc is practically flawless; although there are several repeated phrases (this is a concept album, after all), every song presents something different. There's the gorgeous, lullaby-like 'Cuckoo Cocoon', the abrasive, hard-edged synth rock of 'Back In N.Y.C.', the sweeping, Mellotron-laden 'Fly On A Windshield', and the sinister march of 'The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging'. They even toss out a bona fide prog epic with 'In The Cage', and it's absolutely classic, with bouncy keyboard lines, a pounding rhythm and the amazing "back in the cage…" section which is my pick for the best moment on the entire album.

Alas, my mind starts wandering somewhere around track 11, 'The Chamber of 32 Doors'. The second disc is where things start getting strange; maybe not sonically strange the way 'Grand Parade' was, though you do get to hear some things you wouldn't normally hear on a Genesis record. Much of 'The Waiting Room' is a noise collage à la 'Moonchild', and there are several ambient passages such as 'Silent Sorrow In Empty Boats' or 'Ravine'. In other words, much of the second disc is about atmosphere, though there are a few nice shorter tunes like 'Anyway' or the terrific album closer 'it'. Even 'The Colony Of Slippermen', the disc's analogue to 'In The Cage', seems to tone down the rock factor considerably to focus on the storyline. 

After all, The Lamb is all about the story, and quite frankly it's tough to do it justice here.

If you found Tommy or The Wall hard to follow, The Lamb may just do your head in. Gabriel plays Rael, a young punk who finds himself in Times Square, becomes encrusted in dust, and wakes up in a cage underground. There he finds his brother John, who at first appears as a lifeless husk, then as part of a parade of empty human bodies. Rael reminisces about his life, mostly about what a scoundrel he's been ('Back in N.Y.C.'), but also about his first sexual experience ('Counting Out Time', the album's only moment of comic relief). From there Rael is subjected to what sounds like a lengthy series of Peter Gabriel's bad dreams; we meet carpet crawlers, supernatural anaesthetists, female snake-like creatures called Lamia, and a colony of Slippermen, who (according to the stage show) are lumpy creatures with inflatable genitalia. The idea being that the Lamia seduce Rael and attempt to eat his blood, only to find that it's poison to them, as his blood is somehow corrupted (perhaps, as 'Counting Out Time' suggests, because Rael has lost his innocence).

The Slippermen (of which Rael has become one) are hideous creatures, dedicated only to the pursuit of physical pleasure, leading Rael to understand that the only way to truly free himself and his brother (though John increasingly sounds like a metaphor for Rael's other life) is to "dock the dick". True enlightenment through castration. What's it all mean? 

Well, that's the thing. Lyrically, it's nearly impenetrable, and the several-page-long booklet in the gatefold doesn't help a whole lot. There is a lot of Judeo-Christian imagery - from the symbol of the lamb itself (and a reference to Jonah and the whale), to one of the final lines - "It is real/ It is Rael" ("is real" = Israel?), to the themes of redemption and rebirth. There are references both to Greek mythology (Lamia was a once-beautiful woman who became a hideous creature once her children were taken away) and modern figures ("Lenny Bruce/ declares a truce/ and plays his other hand"). Some of the lines probably only make sense to Peter Gabriel, and others are so open that you could draw any conclusion you wanted to.

Among the narrative there are plenty of stray lines which seem meaningless but can later reveal something (consider the brief "raindrops keep falling on my head" section of 'In The Cage' against the later imagery of ravines and boats). In other words, this is plenty dense, and even after all this time, each spin reveals something new. 

All this is essential to the experience; The Lamb is the rarest of concept albums, where the story really is inseparable from the music. For once, Gabriel plays a relatively normal character the whole way through, reacting to the increasingly crazy things happening around him in a way similar to how you or I would. There is continuity from song to song - sure, songs like 'The Carpet Crawlers' or 'it' may sound great on their own (the former has a claim as the greatest pop song the band ever did), but it's a story that's meant to be followed. This causes the music to become somewhat obscured; you may not notice how many killer basslines Rutherford gets until you actually start listening for them, nor the pure technical skill of Phil Collins, whose playing was starting to hit its peak.

Apparently, the band started to feel this too. The Lamb came slated with an enormous stage show with the scope of an actual Broadway play, and with it came the perception that Genesis was Peter Gabriel's show. This was not exactly a new perception, but The Lamb took everything to new heights, particularly in terms of the press, who could now spend an entire review talking about everything but the actual music. The tour itself became unsustainable; all the money it made was funnelled back in, and the band now laments that only a handful of shows went off without a hitch. Sadly, there is little documented from this era; a more-or-less complete show was released on Genesis Archive, but due to bad recording both Gabriel and Hackett had to re-record some of their parts.

 Well, this is just where progressive rock was at back then. We lionise this era today; there are dozens of new bands determined to pretend it's still 1972, and there exists a Genesis tribute act called The Musical Box that has spent the last 20 years trying to emulate exactly what Genesis was doing in the first half of the 70s (for the record, most tend to agree that they pretty much nail it, particularly Phil Collins who claims "they played it better than we did").

Great prog albums continue to be released right up until today, but those that came after The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway have the benefit of hindsight and often come from outfits who tour less and have more time. Looking back, the class of 1974 were really flying by the seat of their pants, innovating and trying to get bigger at every turn, till it all blew up in their faces. King Crimson, Yes and ELP all (temporarily) split in 1974; the latter two would come back in 1977 to a musical landscape that was very different than the one they'd thrived in. 

As for Genesis, everything had a funny way of working out. Gabriel began his solo career and Collins took over on vocals, and their next two albums went mostly along the same path; hell, much of Wind & Wuthering sounds like an improved version of what happens on disc two of The Lamb, probably because Gabriel was out of the way. But once Steve Hackett left, the band quickly turned pop, and Genesis had the remarkable distinction of having spawned two megastar acts in Peter Gabriel and Phil Collins while remaining a commercially successful act in its own right. It's hard to think of any other band that pulled off anything quite like that, especially considering that the trio of Tony Banks, Mike Rutherford and Phil Collins were the same guys who wrote nearly all the music on The Lamb.

Today, The Lamb stands as a moment in time. It wound up being a UK number 10 and went gold in three countries, and the insane stage show managed to at least break even. After 1974, this sort of success would be unthinkable; while Yes's Going For The One hit number 1 in 1977, it was the last of its kind to do so. After that, you had the Sex Pistols, ABBA, Gary Numan and The Police. Genesis re-tooled their sound and wound up scoring a number 1 album with Duke - it's not entirely divorced from prog (not to the extent of say, the totally un-Yes-like 'Owner Of A Lonely Heart'), but it's so much less obtuse, allowing the listener to enjoy it without having to contemplate the symbolism of hairless hearts and dicks in test tubes being carried off by ravens.

The Lamb still remains an enigma four decades later, long after we've transcribed every last note of Close To The Edge and Tarkus (nowadays, those albums and plenty others come with bonus tracks; something that seems unthinkable with The Lamb). It's not exactly prog's very finest release - Close To The Edge has a better case for that throne, and Genesis themselves hardly have any consensus as to their high point. Hell, if you're more a fan of the band's three-piece incarnation, The Lamb probably isn't even in consideration. But if we're talking about the genre's pinnacle, the one album that tried to outdo everyone else, the one you'd put in a time capsule so the generation of 2074 could understand how strange and amazing and up our own asses we really were, then The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway is it.

If you love our features, news and reviews, please support what we do with a one-off or regular donation. Year-on-year, our corporate advertising is down by around 90% - a figure that threatens to sink The Quietus. Hit this link to find out more and keep on Black Sky Thinking.

J. Eric Smith
Nov 14, 2014 3:13pm

Excellent critique and analysis of a crucial album and amazing period of music history. Those who appreciate both might enjoy this long form exploration into the Greatest Classic Progressive Rock Album Ever:

Reply to this Admin

Cat Vincent
Nov 14, 2014 4:10pm

"the band's lack of a real soloist" - poor Steve Hackett, never gets the love (even on the recent BBC doc)... though thanks for noting it was his departure turned the band from prog to pop.

Lots of The Lamb was explicitly based on Gabriel's dreams - he said that The Lamia was a straight life from a teenage erotic fantasy about woman-headed snakes nibbling him while he floated in a swimming pool full of Ribena!

Reply to this Admin

John Lugg
Nov 14, 2014 7:11pm

Always great to read about modern musical history in long-form. These sort of reads give a good background for younger listeners like myself to connect the dots between the music currently being produced and music from the past.

Reply to this Admin

Nov 14, 2014 9:42pm

In reply to Cat Vincent:

It took me a while to wrap my head around the idea of Steve Hackett occupying a more ornamental role as a guitarist instead of being a Howe or Fripp type when he clearly had the chops. He does have a solo or two on this disc (I forgot where!) but I get the feeling that Banks wasn't exactly keen on letting him do a whole lot.

Reply to this Admin

Tim Niblock
Nov 14, 2014 11:05pm

Is Tago Mago really a prog album?

Reply to this Admin

Nov 15, 2014 11:14am

I've always attributed Genesis turn to pop music due to Hackett's departure, but in here you say that Steve almost didn't contributed to the music in "Lamb"... so... that means that Collins, Rutherford and Banks could've keep making great prog music but decided against it?

Reply to this Admin

J. Eric Smith
Nov 15, 2014 8:36pm

In reply to John Lugg:

Glad you enjoyed the long-form article. It was a lot of fun to research and write. Here's another massive essay of a similar sort where Genesis also make an appearance:

Reply to this Admin

Nov 16, 2014 6:45pm

I was talking to my dad about this, and subject turned to Hackett. I told my dad, who was a 19-year-old prog fan when this record came out, that Hackett seems nearly absent here. My dad looked at me like I'd gone crazy, and pulled out an example: "listen to the beautiful notes he makes during the chorus of Carpet Crawlers! You call that nothing???"... I listened again, and he who listened to this album a billion times was right.

I now return to this every time I want to REALLY LISTEN to music. What an album.

Reply to this Admin

john p.
Nov 16, 2014 10:13pm

This article was a good reason to re-listen to a record which I used to play to death... until punk broke and got me fed up with this bloated progstuff. Anyway, it wasn't as bad as I thought... Some really nice songs like Carpet Crawlers and Anyway. And I love that Eno-esque ending of side three.

I remember prefering Hackett over Yes' Steve Howe, as How's solos seem to lay on top of the music, whereas Hackett's WERe the music. Quite a diffence.

Reply to this Admin

john p
Nov 16, 2014 10:15pm

In reply to john p.:

Quite a DIFFERENCE that is.

Reply to this Admin

Nov 18, 2014 12:17pm

I have always thought that only genesis fans really 'get' Genesis. The Lamb is the album that splits people down the middle. Side one and two are almost perfect. Sides three and four sound like they just didn't know how to end it. A mish mash of ideas just to fill it. However you can just pick tracks out as classics from the morass of instrumental noodling. Back in NYC and The Lamia are awesome, prog or not. The next album, Trick of the Tail, sold more copies, with Collins as singer and then they ditched genius Hackett to go threefold. They became pop stars, for which a lot of people never forgave them. Interesting band though eh? Now let's have an article on the S Club 7 revival...

Reply to this Admin

Nov 20, 2014 5:14pm

There was Genesis before and after Peter Gabriel. The first was much better compared to what came after. The last with Phil Collins was a slot machine.

Reply to this Admin

Oct 12, 2015 11:32am

As others have said, a good thought-piece on this great album. Genesis are unique, there is/was no band like them. It's a shame they are generally so dismissed, if not even vilified, by people who think it's all Invisible Touch and Phil Collins and don't realise the diversity of their output. One thing that bugs me though, is this repeated claim that the 2nd half of the album is weak or patchy. I love the 2nd half, there's some great music and it should be noted that The Waiting Room isn't just an abstract noise collage, no-one ever points out that it beautifully coalesces into a brilliant rock groove which is still my favourite piece of Genesis music.

What a shame they didn't do anything to celebrate its 40th. I did in my own small way; I got a Lamb Lies Down mug from the Genesis online shop!

Reply to this Admin

Feb 18, 2017 6:00am

i enjoyed a lot your review, thanks for sharing your thoughts. The Lamb is my favourite album since i discovered it 25 years ago. i was a newborn when they staged the Lamb but later had the chance to see the tribute band "Musical Box" twice, reenacting the lamb note-by-note: they even borrowed the original slides of the 1974-1975 tour (the first multimedia show?). Certainly they nailed it and it was my only chance to come close to the era we are too young to have witnessed... However, there is also a creepy feeling when one considers a band of gifted guys like these, wasting their talent in cloning the past, instead of letting their own stuff blossom. Also, if you check Kevin Gilbert's 1994 reenacting... that´s another level: Giraffe did not just produce an exact copy but put their souls (and their creativity) on the job... at times they sounded better than the original !

Reply to this Admin