The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website

Reviews

Primal Scream
Beautiful FutureChris Roberts, July 15th, 2008 12:53

Add your comment »

Primal Scream 'Beautiful Future'

The ninth Primal Scream album. Does anyone care any more? Evidently the general music press care quite a lot, although the best they seem to be able to come up with in order to justify their love (The Scream now share Madonna’s PR) is that it’s only rock’n’roll but they - sigh - like it. Whenever you hear a real actual person enthuse about them, which isn’t often, they always seem to be “friends of Bobby”. Do you wanna be in his gang? You’d have to pretend to like some dreary hackneyed music and place a damp cloth over any intellect you might possess, but there’s loads of drugs and impressionable skinny girls around. Kate Moss‘s vacuity-as-resonance is a perfect match for the band‘s body of work.

It’s hard to think of any aesthetic value system under which Primal Scream could be considered meaningful or important. Third generation copy-ism is what they do: they do it almost competently, apart from that piss-awful reedy vocalist, and for less demanding types that’s fun, which they feel is enough.

Of course you’ll find people who claim Screamadelica was a “classic”, that 'Rocks', uh, “rocked”. (It did, but not as much as the Faces album tracks it aped). The first fluked into a zeitgeist that was waved through only because everyone except me was on drugs. 'Loaded', their most enjoyable track, has little to do with them and more to do with Weatherall. It gave its name to lads’ mags, which in turn set back feminism by twenty years. Kudos for that then, boys. Like The Verve, they are about mass drunken get-togethers, where individual sensitivity or thoughtful dissent is to be looked at funny, possibly glassed outside Wetherspoons. Their contribution has not greatly added to the sum of human achievement.

Can Primal Scream sound remotely interesting if you’re not totally wasted? Can they be of any use other than filling in between albums for Stones fans and telling us MC5 are great when MC5 clearly haven’t been great since Harold Wilson was P.M.? What would happen if they were barred from mimicking the tired tropes of the weary old Sixties heroes they unimaginatively revere?

Something like this would happen. On Beautiful Future, they hand over half the production to Paul Epworth and half to Bjorn from Swedish whistlers Peter, Bjorn And John. With the Bloc Party man they sound very choppy, all guitars kept staccato, as you’d expect, to no great effect. With the Swede they aspire not to “Young Folks”-style lilting and lolloping but to Seventies Glam Rock (how many years after Suede and co?). But they get it all wonky. They sound like Sailor.

You won’t remember Sailor. Sailor dropped in on the tail end of Glam Rock, which had by then become Glam Pop. They wore stripy tops. They were harmless enough. Their two most notable hits were “A Glass Of Champagne” and “Girls, Girls, Girls”. One of them had a fling with one of Pan’s People, which may be the most intriguing and surprising thing about them. Primal Scream, getting it all wrong as per, elect not to be influenced by Bowie or Bolan or Roxy or Sparks or even Wizzard. Oh no. Primal Scream try to go Glam by displaying the direct, photocopied influence of Sailor.

When they’re not spending the first two tracks being Sailor, albeit with daft lyrics about “naked bodies hanging from trees” they’re presenting a weak Prince tribute on “Uptown”. It serves only to remind us how well Prince does Prince, even when he‘s not at his best at doing Prince. Getting through this whole review without using the word “karaoke“ is not easy. 'Suicide Bomb' showcases Gillespie’s usual sledgehammer subtlety with words: “gas chambers“ and “nooses“ are exciting imagery to him. He comes across as an idiot savant, except without the savant part. 'Zombie Man' is unwitting self-parody from a band who have to go to pretty ridiculous lengths to reach unwitting self-parody. And do. Lovefoxx, from dreadful, inexplicably acclaimed, office-disco clodhoppers CSS, turns up for some cred by association on “I Love To Hurt” (You Love To Be Hurt”) - ooh, so kinky! So wild and dark and dangerous! Josh Homme plays guitar on “Necro Hex Blues”. So, big whoop. They have friends. Who are in bands.

Oddly, a Fleetwood Mac cover, 'Over And Over', brings Brit-folk oldie Linda Thompson in for a duet. Anyone could sing with more charisma than Gillespie: Thompson certainly does. This will be hailed as a “great” track, you can tell. Yet one of the most distressing trends of the last decade has been the rehabilitation of Fleetwood Mac as media darlings. Fleetwood Mac were bland, mainstream, coked-up hippies with terrible clothes and hair who woke up every morning and wondered how they could sell out in ten different ways before breakfast. They were Jeremy Clarkson’s jeans. They made Sailor seem like Iggy. Quite why they are “cool” again, as opposed to vastly superior genius songwriters The Bee Gees, is unfathomable. Almost as unfathomable as how The Scream have pulled off a lengthy and critically-condoned career without ever having a single original idea. Don’t look for any here, obviously.


Advertisement
jonny mugwump
Jul 15, 2008 12:02pm

Oh thank fuck AT LAST- i loved Screamadelica at the time and now find it ludicrous other than the Orb's production on Higher Than The Sun. Their dub direction was the biggest joke in the world, their various 'rock' directions would have been more convincing with joe pasquale on vocals. The Shields produced tracks on xterminator are however extraordinary but then thats Shields innit?
Of course, they were an indie flirtation with rave culture and people can hang on to that in the vague hope that they had some link to it but let's face it- it just drugs, scenes and bandwagons. Genre hoppers move through passion not stance and The Bug's new album is exactly what happens when one man's musical journey is fuelled by BELIEF rather than cool.

Reply to this Admin

petal affinity
Jul 15, 2008 3:00pm

that was magnifique - surely no-one could have pulled the wheels off this clattering old bandwagon with more elan than Roberts.

Reply to this Admin

grimly fiendish
Jul 15, 2008 10:21pm

hang on. i really liked sailor.

come to that, i really liked "riot city blues", too, but i appreciate that makes me a very unusual person ploughing a very lonely furrow.

whatever. i'm still looking forward to this.

Reply to this Admin

Amit Sud
Jul 16, 2008 12:27am

I do enthuse about Primal Scream, and I am not friends with Bobby, nor do I want be in his gang.

I do remeber Sailor, stop being patronising please.

There have been some lackluster Primal Scream albums (in my humble opinion of course) but there have been some excellent Primal Scream albums filled with original ideas. XTRMNTR, Evil Heat, Screamadelica to name a few.

It is easy to think of an 'aesthetic value system' which Primal Scream can be considered to be meaningful or important. This album may not have an original idea. It might not be a good album: I have not heard it.

Half of this album review described:

a) The PR status of Primal Scream
b) What people who hang out with Bobby are like
c) The types of people that listen to their albums

Please make the article shorter. Thanks

Reply to this Admin

Matthew K
Jul 17, 2008 4:59am

Would Chris care to specify where on "Over and Over" Linda Thompson sings? Or is it possible he reviewed the album without listening to it?

Reply to this Admin

Jeffrey Belengazi
Jul 17, 2008 3:05pm

Back in the knife draw, bitter Ms. Blunt.

Reply to this Admin

Jeffrey Belengazi Jeffrey Dahmer
Jul 17, 2008 3:10pm

In reply to Jeffrey Belengazi:

Christ, I read the review and got the impression it was the work of a bitter, ugly female.
Turned out to be written by Chris Roberts whose work in Melody Maker I used to enjoy back in
the day. Whatever happened?

Reply to this Admin

Bobby Beausoleil
Jul 17, 2008 3:18pm

In reply to petal affinity:

Ho ho. Shame then it's published in such an obscure backwater as this blog. No
paying work to be found, Herr. Roberts? What a fucking surprise!

Reply to this Admin

Tim Russell
Jul 18, 2008 4:17am

This is the most entertaining review I've read for ages, & takes me back to the days when music journalism was about criticism rather than PR.

As for the Scream, they've not made a decent album since XTRMNTR.

Reply to this Admin

paul duffy
Jul 20, 2008 7:35pm

your intense hatred of bobby.g and co is some what justified. But their music on the whole is rather fine on the whole. Every single record i listen too is derivative to some degree or another.
Bring back the glitter band for my own sanity.

Reply to this Admin

do1 frood
Jul 21, 2008 2:09pm

An excellent read but somewhat heavy with the dissage. PS are an easy target; there must be some positive chink of light? And as for the swift slating of Fleetwood Mac, oh please, "Rumours" is one of the finest albums ever made. There's nothing wrong with pilferage of music gone by. Zeppelin, The Beatles and The Stones were thieving all over the shop, and it introduces unheard music to a new audience. But the uncredited rip-off of Ringo's "Back off Boogaloo" for "Zombie Man" is a classic. I say, Steal away! but be wary of lawyers. All this retro 80s stuff at the mo: Alphabeat, Bloc Party, Mystery Jets - it's like the Brinks Mat of music.

Reply to this Admin

steve tolley
Jul 29, 2008 10:41am

You wrote:
'Loaded', their most enjoyable track, has little to do with them and more to do with Weatherall. It gave its name to lads’ mags, which in turn set back feminism by twenty years. Kudos for that then, boys.

That's sound logic. Bhuddists invented the swastika, Nazis steal swastika, Bhuddists responsible for holocaust.

Also you mentioned nothing about the actual album you just slagged the band off, which is fine but back some of it up. I'm reviewing this album for another site and I actually think there are some positives on it. Sure there are some clunky lyrics and they haven't rewrittien the musical rulebook here, but so what? Who has recently?
And by the way for what its worth Screamadelica is a classic album. So there.

Reply to this Admin

Matthew K
Aug 2, 2008 8:06am

In reply to Matthew K:

My apologies for the implied insult - the version I heard had only Bobby G on vocals. And the album is largely a dog, but you won't hear a bad word from me about Vanishing Point, XTRMNTR or Evil Heat, and even Riot City Blues is decent enough.

Reply to this Admin