The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website

The Quietus Essay

How Motorik Infected The Mainstream, By Future Days Author David Stubbs
David Stubbs , August 7th, 2014 06:39

David Stubbs, author of Future Days: Krautrock And The Building Of Modern Germany, published recently by Faber, looks at how the influence of Klaus Dinger's drumming spread far and wide

Add your comment »

Brian Eno would declare the Dingerbeat devised by Neu!'s Klaus Dinger to be one of the three great beats of the 1970s, along with James Brown/Clyde Stubblefield's funk and Fela Kuti/Tony Allen's Afrobeat. It's also known as motorik, a word with an ultra-modernistic, Teutonic sheen but one which was actually coined to describe the work of the pre-war German composer Paul Hindemith who, in works like the Sonata For Solo Cello Opus 25, sought to emulate the industrial rhythms that were a new addition to the sonic environment of the early 20th century. Today, in the early 21st century, motorik is ubiquitous. Linear and propulsive, it features in the music of Toy, Cold Pumas, Kasabian and The Horrors, among many others. Even The Manics have taken on board its Germanic element to a degree with their latest album Futurology, while Noel Gallagher has declared himself a Neu! fan.

This isn't entirely surprising - for those with its interests at heart, popular rock is in ecological crisis, with few places left to "go" structurally. Dingerbeat, which has been characterised by musician and Can associate Jono Podmore as a 4/4 tempo with the accents constantly on the beat, represents a new lifeline. Traditional West African-based African-American musics like 'The Funky Drummer' backbeat are, he says, "structured over two bars – one bar with the accent on the beat, the next with the accent off the beat. This forms a duality – breathe out, breathe in. The Dingerbeat just breathes out – a single line, a constant process. Not circular but driving from A to wherever." With its tantric build-up of intensity and fast-moving, picaresque backdrop, the motorik beat offers a thrillingly accessible alternative to the old model. Play motorik and you can hurtle past the old necessities of bridge and chorus like so many turn-offs and service stations. Fast forward, onward.

And yet, it's not so long ago that motorik as a precursor to today's rock languished in relative oblivion. Sure, there were Can and Kraftwerk, who could intermittently be claimed to be practitioners of the genre - 'Autobahn' is an obvious example, though it bowls along at a relatively languid pace and goes through various gears, while Can's 'Moonshake', a small, perfectly formed piece of robo-pop from 1973, inspired a UK band of the same name. Then there was 'Mother Sky', which proceeds across its own landscape in a manner celebrated by Loop on their cover of the song in the 1980s, or Faust's more primitive take on the beat, 'It's A Rainy Day, Sunshine Girl'. Faust, Can and Kraftwerk albums were available in the late 1980s. Much harder to get hold of, however, were the albums of Neu! - and, with no YouTube to sate the curious, they become the stuff of mythology, tantalisingly alluded to by older music press journos, namechecked by Sonic Youth in their songs.

Neu!'s back catalogue was eventually reissued thanks to the best efforts of German rock star Herbert Grönemeyer, who decided to start his own label, not least to benefit other German artists less fortunate than himself. Prior to that, however, throughout the 1990s, a series of disputes between Michael Rother and the irascible, embroiled Dinger (who released Neu! material unauthorised by his own partner) meant that the only way you could actually get to hear this legendary 70s duo was via old rare vinyl or cassettes. My friend, the late Neil Jones, made me a compilation of Neu! material, along with similarly unavailable tracks by Harmonia and early Kraftwerk (who you feel would rather everyone pretended they hadn't existed prior to 1974). I also had a copy of Neu! 75, which I'd bought from a university friend who was anxious to obtain funds for four pints of lager. These had a certain cachet in the rock underworld.

The most significant group to popularise the motorik beat were Stereolab in the 1990s, to startling effect, and while their success was built on the chassis of the 4/4 beat, it would be simplistic indeed to dismiss them retrospectively as Neu! imitators taking advantage of audiences who hadn't heard the "real thing". Stereolab's music contained submerged elements of Krautrock which also included Kraftwerk and Faust, while there was an equally significant Gallic counterpoint to their music, with Laetitia Sadier's vocals hinting at a great lost French tradition of avant-pop that never crossed over. This Franco-Germanic musical alliance represented an imaginary, appetising alternative to the Anglo-American hegemony of the 80s and 90s.

Stereolab launched a thousand bands in the 1990s; indeed, it's likely that many of today's Neu! fans heard Stereolab before they ever heard the likes of 'Hallogallo' first-hand. As such, there became for a long time an element of tupperware, fuzzbox retro-futurism attached to the 1990s generation of 4/4-ers, who took their cue from the likes of 'French Disko' rather than Rother and Dinger - groups like Pram, Quickspace Supersport, Add N to (X), Broadcast, as well as the countless little drum, guitar and cheap organ-based combos who played at the Kosmische club that decade. At best, these groups expanded into more experimental, psychedelic, individualistic terrain; at worst the Stereolab sound became, frankly, a cliche.

Now that Neu! are freely available, they have become more widely disseminated. They crop up in all kinds of places. Here, they are, for example, soundtracking one of Adam Curtis's typically thoughtful and laterally inspired blogs. More pertinently, they've been a direct influence on a host of new bands obscure and otherwise, including Caribou, Baltic States and, from their own country, Camera - a generation of groups who have dispensed with the kitsch frills of their 90s forebears and for whom motorik is a highly effective, heads-down way of generating raw rock energy, full throttle, sparks flying upward.

It's arguable that motorik isn't an exclusively German phenomenon - that, coincidentally or otherwise, other sometimes improbable artists have alighted on a similar beat. In America, it ties in with that familiar rock & roll artery, the road, most obviously in Canned Heat's 'On The Road Again', and later, Jonathan Richman's 'Roadrunner', as well as Suicide's 'Ghost Rider' - there are common thematic points with Neu! in all of these - the imperative to keep moving, the tantric relentless and waiving of the respite of a chorus, the underlying sorrow of a journey that takes you a long way from the comforts of home, hearth and conventionality. There's a variation on motorik in Hawkwind, on 1975's 'Opa Loka' which proceeds upward into the cosmos at a chug which would be familiar with those acquainted with Neu!, though again, there's a subtle difference between this and the sleeker, more mobile Dingerbeat.

Still stranger are those occasions when popular artists appear almost inadvertently to have alighted on the motorik beat, such as Nilsson's 'Jump Into The Fire' - whose deadly build-up was put to such good use in Martin Scorsese's Goodfellas - or the first couple of minutes of The Supremes' 'All I Want' from 1972 ("I am on a lonely road that I am travelling"), before it takes a conventional right turn.

Coincidence, or were these ideas spreading quickly and virally among beatmakers across the globe? What's for certain is that only in Krautrock were they applied consciously and with such rigour and consistency.

There's clearly an urgent, abiding appeal to motorik, from both a playing and a listening point of view. For both Klaus Dinger and Jaki Liebezeit, it was to do with a relationship between man and machine that was slightly at odds with that proposed by Kraftwerk. Dinger, who played with Ralf Hütter and Florian Schneider in an early incarnation of the ‘Werk, took personal affront at the idea of players like himself being replaced by machinery - as would, of course, be the fate of many of his kind with the onset of electronic music. Both he and Liebezeit proposed an alternative - human beings emulating machines. (There's a story of a musician in a rehearsal room below Liebezeit's being thoroughly irritated by a precise percussive loop coming from upstairs - over and over, for hours and hours, as if someone had gone out for the day having inadvertently left a drum programme switched on. They went upstairs to investigate, only to find out that it was Liebezeit practising). Motorik equals the liberation of rigidity.

Motorik, however does not equal Krautrock - a common misconception. It's a brilliant starting point for those new to the genre, but not its defining trope. It's only even a part of what's going on across Neu!'s albums, which are bipolar affairs; after kicking off at sanguine 4/4 pace they invariably slow right up, as if stricken by the limpid melancholy of having arrived far too early at their destination - the disappointment of arrival after travelling hopefully. Motorik is groovy indeed but Krautrock in all its vast, topographical divergence is beyond groovy - it represents vast, off-road fertile plains, thick forests, complex power plants and, upward and beyond, the black night and the future undawned. There's nowhere left for rock to go but everywhere, and motorik is the quickest and straightest road ahead to that old/new beyond.

Future Days: Krautrock And The Building Of Modern Germany is out now on Faber

If you love our features, news and reviews, please support what we do with a one-off or regular donation. Year-on-year, our corporate advertising is down by around 90% - a figure that threatens to sink The Quietus. Hit this link to find out more and keep on Black Sky Thinking.

Aug 7, 2014 11:59am

To be honest, with the current crop of Kraut-inspired rockers, I think motorik has been done to death already. Even some of the better bands like BEAK>, Föllakzoid etc, rely on it too easily.

Reply to this Admin

Aug 7, 2014 12:01pm

"it's likely that many of today's Neu! fans heard Stereolab before they ever heard the likes of 'Hallogallo' first-hand." Ha! Absolutely dead on. In fact, when I was a teenage I was really snobby about krautrock calling it 'hippy-shit' and the like, whilst listening to Tortoise, Stereolab, Add N to X, PiL etc. The precociousness of youth...

Reply to this Admin

Post-Punk Monk
Aug 7, 2014 1:06pm

Then I am fortunate, because I have Neu! albums and have never heard Stereolab! Nice to see Camera namechecked. Their debut album "Radiate!" is an exciting album. As for Jonathan Richman and "Roadrunner," let's not forget that he points to the elephant in the room of motorik beats and quite possibly Krautrock itself; The Velvet Underground. Tracks like "What Goes On," and particularly, "Sister Ray" might have been pivotal to the development of Krautrock.

Reply to this Admin

Aug 8, 2014 12:55am

Fuck off- "...rock has few interesting places to ' go ' structurally... "- such a stupid and shallow analysis. Get an imagination idiot. Go dig ditches, you'd be better off than writing such bollocks criticism.

Reply to this Admin

Aug 8, 2014 5:18am

Stereolab were around and operating in 1990, three years before Siamese Dream came about, if you want to go there man. But who cares

Reply to this Admin

Aug 8, 2014 8:38am

Im not sure i may have read it on another article on this site but did the guys from Neu! claim that they never called the beat Motorik and the term actually came from how they described playing football against members of Kraftwerk because the guys were that fit they just never stopped running?

Reply to this Admin

Aug 8, 2014 10:18pm

In reply to Bartoli:

Very true! Dinger always referred to it as Apache-beat. Motorik is a punning really. It means "motor skill" which any good drummer will need, certainly, if he is playing this beat constantly.

Reply to this Admin

Aug 9, 2014 6:28am

In reply to :

Oh, you disagree do you? Well how about making a little fucking effort to express yourself in a less hateful and ignorant way? Nah, that'd require thoughtful consideration of the kind Stubbs has and you lack. Personally I agree with him, but I won't waste more words on you.

Reply to this Admin

Aug 10, 2014 11:38am

Interesting article, I thought.

As for the Smashing Pumpkins idea, well chronology is a funny thing, isn't it? If only Smashing Pumpkins did it before Stereolab, then you might have a point. As they didn't, you don't.

Reply to this Admin

Simon Blinkho
Aug 12, 2014 10:10am

Ringo Starr did Motorik with The Plastic Ono Band in 1970:

Reply to this Admin

Sep 1, 2014 2:17pm

Personally, I don't understand the value of judging a band by those who might have been 'influenced' by them or stolen a riff, or sampled something from them. The value of Neu!'s work is in their own music. All four albums are great, even the new one from the '80s sessions. Same goes for VU. To appreciate them, just listen to their own music. I like Yo La Tengo and Stereolab, but listening to them does not tell me how vibrant and striking the music of VU or Neu! is. It's a singular thing.

Reply to this Admin

Jonny Chinchen
Sep 13, 2014 2:07am

The best point made in the article is how little this one drum beat is in relation to all the musical life thriving in Germany in the late 60's and 70's.
There's never a dull moment with Amon Duul, Ash Tray Temple were smoking, Cluster were lining up their Eno collaboration, while Faust were signing a pact with the devil.
Neu and Can were great, but just a small part of the puzzle.
It's a shame that indie rock took beats from Hallogallo, riff from Mother Sky and left it there.
The rest of "Krautrock" is a bit hairy for the anemic indie guitar scene, I spose...

Reply to this Admin

Sean Oliver
Dec 7, 2014 7:57pm

In reply to Jonny Chinchen:

'Ash Tray Temple' ha ha. Good one!
Funny how so many rock types think they're experts on music, when they aren't. With about 90% of all music - and 99% of pop/rock - every bar is in 4/4, including Fela, James Brown, and everybody else (except the Shaggs). Jazz is often played in more unusual time, like 5/4 ('Take Five' by Dave Brubeck is, as its name says, in 5/4) Waltzes are in 3/4, and Ethopian jazz like Mulatu Asteke is usually in variations of 3/4 like 6/8, or 6/4, all of which are known as 'triple' time. The characterization of 'the Dinger/motorik beat' as somehow vastly different from other rock/funk drumming because it's 'accents are always on the beat' is a misunderstanding of time signature; how 4/4 can be subdivided into eighths, sixteenths, etc. and still be 'on the beat'. All rock drummers place accents on the beat - if they didn't, they would sound amateurish and/or terrible. Herr Dinger simply doesn't add as many little rolls and fills as most other drummers, that's all. Hardly a huge departure. And the comments describing W. African drumming as 'one bar played on-the-beat, and the next off' are total baloney.

Reply to this Admin

Miki Yui
Oct 29, 2015 10:31pm

Klaus did never liked the term "motoric". He called it Apach, more like Native American way.

His beat was "on the beat" , though in that "on" there was fine differences between pushing and pulling. Klaus learned Architecture, and carpentry, he had sharp sense if what is straight, what has exactly 90 degrees angle, what is not. So he could make fine and subtle differences in playing straight. You could feel the energy pulling you or pushing you, kicking your butt...

He was trained so that he can hit tiny nail with hammer, also with drums, he could hit so hard and still be very precise and not stiff. his arms moves so elastic. "Hammer Beat" some say.

"Minimalismus" is also one of the important term in Düsseldorf art/music.
Also interesting differences between Klaus and Jaki Liebezeit Drumming. Klaus on Bass drum and Jaki on Tom.

miki yui

Reply to this Admin
Jan 15, 2016 10:39pm

the peter gunn theme by henry mancini is pretty motorik!

Reply to this Admin