The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website

Three Songs No Flash

Still Dirty On The Inside: Nine Inch Nails Live
Luke Turner , August 21st, 2013 06:11

On the evidence of last night's Scala show, Nine Inch Nails have recharged their batteries in spectacular style, writes Luke Turner, highlighting the subtle undercurrents that run through their precision techno-metal

Add your comment »

Photos by Kate Beard

There's an air of both chaos and anticipation outside the Scala, where Nine Inch Nails are playing an ultra-rare warm-up show for this weekend's Reading Festival. Will anyone get in? Is it actually possible to move past NIN's five-foot-wide American bouncer, stood by the door in a black suit and sending people in three directions at once? Will it be all new material from forthcoming LP Hesitation Marks? Are we all too old for all this buff angst? Clearly not - this crowd (where the hell are all the goths?) can scream enough when the lights drop, dry ice fills the stage lit by flashes of blue... And their voices rise in crescendo as Trent Reznor's short, muscular frame emerges through the smoke...

And The Scala explodes with 'Somewhat Damaged', which takes the recorded version from 1999's Fragile as a mere sketch compared to the tectonic force it becomes live. I don't think I've ever seen a band this tight, this hard, this physical. Every well-drilled blast has jackhammer impact, more grubby techno than rock band, and indeed much of tonight's power comes from the focus on electronics over guitars. Yet the fact that NIN so very much are a rock band, and a brilliant American rock band at that, is evident in the leadership of Trent Reznor. Every raw flexed sinew of this music suggests that those muscles in his arms are about to burst through his skin and start writhing around the room. In recent photos he's looked like a demure, cashmere jumper wearing CEO of a successful dot com enterprise. Tonight he's a brawny figurehead, still a gladiator taking arms for the disaffected. "Nothing can stop me now" he sings in the digital bum dungeon sleaze of 'Piggy', leaning out over the crowd, who scream it back to him.

We are in an age where bands don't really split, but disappear for a bit before regrouping, calling it what they may. Yet who's to say that's actually a bad idea, especially if an honest sabbatical can recharge their batteries like this. It might be a greatest hits sort of evening, with precious little from the new album (it's actually a shame not to hear this line-up play the Factory Floor-cousin 'Copy Of A'), but Nine Inch Nails glow with vitality - you get the distinct impression that the new album isn't likely to the sort of 'will this do?' rehash of two decades ago that so many returning veterans limply phone in. Maybe it's the intimacy of the venue, but Trent Reznor's young band, as adept with drum machines and synths as guitars, make this feel as searing fresh as a winter's icy dawn. With guitars, bass, drums back right, keys left, the set-up is rather more compressed on the Scala's stage than the spread out, black-clad SWAT team Kraftwerk arrangement deployed in larger venues. They grind it out beautifully, from the blast beat rockabilly of 'Gave Up' to more cartoony moments like 'Wish'. Its "you know me I hate everyone" chorus sounds formidable when delivered with this precision, and a man disappears into the circle pit that whirls in front of us, holding his head, mouth agape.

Yet for all the violence, this is pop music, the clue to which is the digi-funk and appropriation of Gary Numan's Pleasure Principle synths in 'Closer' - you could imagine the boys of One Direction doing it as karaoke and their legions of fans not batting an Accessorised eyelid. And 'Head Like A Hole' is still a sinister earworm of the highest order.

The pointed focus is especially evident on new track 'Disappointed'. A violin on one side of the stage and an Erhu (a stick-like traditional Chinese instrument) on the other make a looping, siren sound, drum machine patters out anxiously as high hats and Trent on tambourine create a weird, railway arch grimy nightclub at 4am vibe. Happily for everyone looking forward to the new album, it's one of the most exciting moments of the evening and showcases the sheer diversity of sound and texture that NIN are capable of within one set. Interestingly, 'Disappointed' is closest in feel to the sounds Coil and others brought to Nine Inch Nails in the Further Down The Spiral remix album than anything they've done since.

Thinking on the long-time Reznor collaborators Peter Christopherson and Jhon Balance for a moment, until now Nine Inch Nails to me have seemed to be, for all their alternative signifiers, overly macho - Coil's "ritual accumulation of male sexual energy" de-queered and turned into motivational music for a goth field hockey team. Tonight, though, it all clicks into place and I get that glorious moment as a critic when you realise that you've been spectacularly wrong. Nine Inch Nails took industrial's sedition and heavy sexuality and souped it up, taking electronic extremism into a guitar realm. And yes, they made it more macho - America is a frontier country, it goes with the territory, which is why the rumble of 'Sanctified' sounds like the Young Gods smashing out a railway cutting.

For sedition to work it has to adopt and subvert that which it stands against - to be un-American you must also be ur- and uber-American, just as Throbbing Gristle portrayed the slide of late 70s Britain by standing atop Beachy Head, still resonant as a symbol of WWII defiance. This is what the new American supposed alternative has largely forgotten, and why after 90 minutes of precision techno metal assault, a cover of Joy Division's 'Dead Souls' and the hymnal 'Hurt' is a finale of moving, infinite grace. It's why the power and the pomp and the glory of Nine Inch Nails means they're as important now in matters of the personal and political as they ever were. Still dirty on the inside.

If you love our features, news and reviews, please support what we do with a one-off or regular donation. Year-on-year, our corporate advertising is down by around 90% - a figure that threatens to sink The Quietus. Hit this link to find out more and keep on Black Sky Thinking.

Chris Thatcher
Aug 21, 2013 11:37am

'Interestingly, 'Disappointed' is closest in feel to the sounds Coil and others brought to Nine Inch Nails in the Further Down The Spiral remix'

If this is born out on the new album then I'm excited... a lot! My first experience of NIN was the Further Down The Spiral remix album and it's still the one I listen to most frequently.

Great review. Thanks!

Reply to this Admin

Aug 21, 2013 12:39pm

i hate every single person who managed to get into this gig. you're all scum.

Reply to this Admin

Aug 21, 2013 1:09pm

Saw them at Pukkelpop over the weekend, an excellent performance only let down by the daylight and the hordes of Eminemfans (or interested) waiting for the next gig to arrive.

Reply to this Admin

James L
Aug 21, 2013 1:48pm

Am still reeling from the gig. The best I've seen them play... they seem fully revitalised. Absolutely outstanding show.

Reply to this Admin

Aug 21, 2013 6:25pm

Surely everyone has heard this by now:

This particular mash-up demonstrates how enduring "Head Like A Hole" can be. I haven't been interested in Nine Inch Nails in decades, but this concoction brought it all back to me.

Reply to this Admin

Aug 21, 2013 7:07pm

I don't own any of their material tho i've always respected what they produce. I've had the opportunity to see them live twice (a free ticket from a friend one time and i bought a ticket to see Bauhaus as their opener on another occasion) and was blown away by how good they are. A fan-fookin'-tastic live act and both times were in large venues. To see them at a venue this small had to have been unbelievable. I'd happily see them again any time.

Reply to this Admin

Aug 21, 2013 7:20pm

they have always been a great live band, but this current incarnation and stage show looks unbelievable! really hope i get to see it.

Reply to this Admin

Aug 21, 2013 8:34pm

I went to this gig, and it was great! I've seen the high production of nin at bigger venues, with all the incredible light shows that they normally bring, but this was so close up, raw and intimate, and I loved every second of it. NIN really are one if the tightest live bands ever, and since Trent is the only permanent member, it's testament to his professionalism that this is consistently true!

Reply to this Admin

Aug 22, 2013 1:05am

Good review, I thought your comments on misunderstanding Nine Inch Nails initially were interesting because I've heard similar things before. cEvin from Skinny Puppy said he didn't like how a NIN show was like a Bruce Springsteen show in terms of audience identification. A friend of mine called Trent "a cultural vampire." I guess I always thought this was exactly what made the band brilliant, even though I can't quite relate to the angst as much as I did as a teenager. Seeing a new way to connect the dots between different types of music can be its own kind of genius - it takes a pretty unique imagination to come up with a way to make a sonic palate akin to Coil and Ministry into stadium-demolishing pop music.

Reply to this Admin

Kevin Spencer
Aug 22, 2013 6:55pm

I watched the livestream of the Lollapalooza festival gig the other week. Fantastic live show. Utterly brilliant performance all round. The homage to Talking Heads as the band walked on one by one during Copy Of A was a nice touch I thought.

Reply to this Admin

Donovan Bell
Mar 11, 2015 12:58pm

Nine inch Nails are a band I've wanted to see live for a very long time. The first lot of NIN I listened to came from the movie "The Crow" the song being "Dead Souls". From that point onwards I really wanted to buy their album..So I went out and bought "The Downward Spiral". I was not disappointed.

Reply to this Admin

Mark Tolley
Jun 12, 2015 12:16pm

In reply to Donovan Bell:

I can say that I have seen Nine Inch Nails live and that it was a brilliant performance. I saw them at the Wiltern Theatre in America back in 2009. Their performance of "The Hand That Feeds" was amazing.

Reply to this Admin