The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website


New Order
Lost Sirens Mick Middles , February 1st, 2013 05:35

Add your comment »

The portents were not good. A mini album featuring eight outtakes from New Order's rather lackadaisical 2005 album, Waiting for the Siren's Call hardly made me bubble with feverish anticipation. While 'Siren's had its moments, it disappointingly proved to be the sound of a famously splintering dynamic and, frankly, a place where the magic had finally started to run dry.

The band's haphazard British tour of the same time only served to confirm these suspicions. Barney grumpy, Hooky aloof, Morris scowling behind the drums. New Order, one of the greatest and most distinctive British bands of the 80s and 90s, always seemed like slaves to their own curious mix of personality, angst, naiveté and sheer bloody minded arrogance. Take those defining aspects away and you are left with an empty palette.

For the most part, Lost Sirens does little to alter this rather sad affair, despite its historical significance. For it is the last New Order album to feature the driving bass and growl of Peter Hook. Unless, that is, the major Mancunian rift miraculously twists into back-slapping camaraderie. Doubt it, frankly.

So here we are. Sifting through the debris. One play is enough to confirm that defining moments refuse to peak through the murk. Oddly for New Order, who always so effortlessly seemed to stumble upon the shards of their own genius, this is a somewhat rounded album where even Hooky's low-end resonance presence remains intriguingly muted. In place of time honoured New Order sound, we find a tenuous mush that, while never astounding, is not necessarily unattractive.

The marriage between electro-pulse and Barney's spindly guitar works well on 'Californian Grass', which is as dreamy and introspective as the title suggests, as is the lilting 'I Stay With You'. However, while Barney remains one of the most underrated guitarists of the past 30 years; his vocal-timing here constantly fails to command attention. Also missing is his loveable steely belligerence. Indeed, these sound like pilot vocals on initial work-outs, which could easily be the case.

Only one track truly holds any trace of surprise. The closing, 'I Told You So', casts the mind back to The Velvet Underground's subversive classic 'Venus In Furs' which is not, frankly, where I expected this album, or indeed Hooky period New Order to lead to. Nevertheless, it offers the only moments of true intensity on an album that might have faired better as an additional curiosity on some lavish box set. Lost Sirens is effectively an exercise in feeding the completists.

If you love our features, news and reviews, please support what we do with a one-off or regular donation. Year-on-year, our corporate advertising is down by around 90% - a figure that threatens to sink The Quietus. Hit this link to find out more and keep on Black Sky Thinking.

Grumpy Bob
Feb 1, 2013 10:39am

Well, there's usually a reason for outtakes being outtakes!

Reply to this Admin

Feb 1, 2013 2:42pm

I would give it 3.5/ 5. It is a good album but it could have been better if they didn’t break up. Sugarcane, I’ll stay with you and Hellbent sound very good. I like Hellbent from the total version better than the original mix. If you like good uplifting music with great melodies and catchy songs then you will love this album, if you are a casual or a diehard New Order fan then you will like this album also.

New order, what a Great band, what a Great life.

Reply to this Admin

Feb 1, 2013 3:31pm

I think you're a bit harsh, and I do hope you listened to it more than once (I'd have given the thumbs down to many NO albums, let alone those of other artists on the first few hearings). It's not spectacular nor particularly unexpected, but Hellbent, I've got a feeling and Californian Grass, as well as the other tracks you mention, would have improved the original album. Less sure about Recoil and Shake it Up though! I think it's well worth a listen and would give it 7/10.

Reply to this Admin

Tooth Ache
Feb 1, 2013 4:36pm

Couldn't agree more.

It's all a bit of a sad state of affairs really.

I preferred the unruly, un-commercial, uncompromising version that died the day they signed to London.

Looking forward to the next 'best of' though.

Reply to this Admin

Feb 1, 2013 10:38pm

Seriously, I'm surprised anybody is still listening...

Reply to this Admin

Feb 4, 2013 9:47am

It's a disappointing album made worse by the way the occasional flashes of genius serve to remind you that the rest of the album isn't.

They can, and will, do better.

Reply to this Admin

Feb 5, 2013 8:01pm

There are some great moments on this record (Californian Grass wouldn't be out of place on Technique) which only show the lack of quality control on Waiting For the Sirens Call.
All a bit tawdry now sadly..

Reply to this Admin