The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website

Features

Voracious Stylistic Promiscuity: Frank Zappa Reissues 1966 - 1972
Ringo P. Stacey , October 8th, 2012 06:34

Everyone at the Quietus is either Frank Zappa sceptic or phobic. Ringo P Stacey tells us why we are wrong in his review of the first 12 reissues

Add your comment »

It's ten years since I sold the last of my Frank Zappa albums, three since I started to regret it. Or rather, not regret it but hanker after buying a few of them back. Why? The way I see it, nostalgia is a disease. For those seven years when I felt his music had no relevance to my life pulling out one of the albums would have been malingering. Unfortunately, by the time I listened again to discover, actually, his music was more relevant than ever, the music was pretty damn difficult to find.

Especially the early stuff. Take Weasels Ripped My Flesh, chronologically the ninth of these re-issues and at one point an album I'd claim to be my 'FAVOURITE ALBUM OF ALL TIME', by any artist, in any genre. Originally released in 1970, I was lucky enough to acquire a vinyl copy in the early 90s from someone who thought it was a horrible atonal mess (rather than the beautiful atonal mess it actually is). Once I'd worn that out I bought the CD.

Big mistake. I'd have been better off saving up for another vinyl copy. Zappa was someone whose career could be considered a tragedy in the purest sense. A classic workaholic perfectionist, obsessed with recorded sound, he was quick to grasp the fundamental differences between vinyl and CD. Deciding that his entire catalogue needed revising to meet the needs of this new medium, he spent an indecent chunk of the last nine years of his life creating a discographical nightmare. Weasels lost a couple of essential seconds at the climax of one track, replaced by three decent but irrelevant minutes that totally disrupted the flow of the album. It'd been subjected to a clumsy remix, smothered in reverb to disguise tape hiss then botched through some nasty filter that seemed to deposit wow and flutter randomly, like a kitten had been playing at one end of the mixing desk. Yet Weasels escaped lightly compared to We're Only In It For The Money and Cruising With Ruben And The Jets, both of whom ended up with entirely new bass and drum tracks.

Some people might think this is the kind of thing Zappa fans relish, think we're the type of perverts who actually get off on it. Any Zappa disciples who haven't read Ian Penman's classic 1995 anti-Zappa rant in The Wire should head over to their online archive now to see what the plastic people think of you. Got it? Looking for "get out clauses from the idea of simple plain fun"? Wanting to "collate and collect and fanzine-date each and every guitar solo into cultural, slo-death oblivion"? Nah, not me matey. I just want to play the music loud without feeling too queasy.

And now I can. And so can you do too! This latest re-issue campaign, the second since Zappa's death in 1993, marks the first major posthumous attempt to repair the worst of the damage inflicted on his catalogue in the 80s and early 90s. Hopefully it should also mark a resurgence of evangelism by the Zappa massif, a chance to whole-heartedly recommend his most accessible works in unbotched form, to refute the most heinous lies peddled by the likes of Penman and his misguided brethren. Not everything has been restored, but the majority of Zappa's pre-digital catalogue will finally be available once more in a form somewhat close to what was originally intended.

Note the qualifier. Not everything has been restored. Not all of the tinkering Zappa did was incompetent, some of it was merely tasteless. One album remaining in remixed form is The Mothers Of Invention's debut Freak Out! from 1966. Never one of my favourite albums, it really doesn't bother me so much that Zappa decided it'd be a good idea to tweak the drums so they'd sound like they were jacked from a session by Huey Lewis & The News. It may bother those who think this is an album of historical import, pivotal not only in Zappa's story but the LA freak scene it documents. They've got a point, but in either edition Freak Out is, bizarrely, too timid and polite to endure unscathed into the twenty-first century. The first half is a knowing but mediocre psychedelic pop record. The second half is more assured, especially the square white funk of 'Help I'm A Rock' and the genuinely sinister serial killer posed barbershop quartet of 'It Can't Happen Here', but ultimately falls flat with 'Return Of The Son Of Monster Magnet', a failed experiment involving a bunch of hipsters, some LSD and a room full of percussion, possibly the most tedious track in the entire Zappa catalogue.

Era-fetishists may like to start with Freak Out, most everyone else should note its existence and jump straight to the superior sequel Absolutely Free (1967). Much later the Mothers' original lead singer Ray Collins would comment of his successors, “All the guys in Frank's band seem seem to do what they think The Mothers of Invention are supposed to do. They all try to act zany.” He's right, some of the later bands worked brilliantly within the established confines, but none had the sense of gleeful anarchy, of defining form. Of purpose. They were all trying to ape Absolutely Free, the riotous sound of an creative revolution in full swing, the perfect balance between idealism and incredulity. Or, to be slightly less romantic, a point where The Mothers were comfortable enough to start dicking about in the studio, holding back the giggles as they took the piss out of straight society, improvising lyrics about cheesy prunes through moonbeams in June. This version is as near to perfect as makes no difference, a fresh master free of echo, revealing every glorious nuance of the original.

We're Only In It For The Money (1968) has a similar clarity and may technically be a better album, if you're the type who likes to quantify these things. By this point Zappa had more resources at his disposal, a larger band, more money for equipment and studio time, more experience directing the whole operation, all the ingredients necessary to make a grand statement. Money is an album of its time, one finds Zappa fully tuned in to prevailing trends. If it were funny it might mark Zappa's peak as a satirist. As it is there's no such risk, its humour is bleak and undermined by an uncharacteristic aura of despondent resignation. It doesn't help that Ray Collins temporary absence left the group without a vocalist capable of any subtlety. We're Only In It For The Money may be a great formal achievement, a timely piece of social comment but it's also a deeply tedious album to listen to.

Much better is Zappa's solo debut Lumpy Gravy (1968), recorded at the same time as Money with some material in common but an entirely different experience. Though they may have pushed the boundaries, all three Mothers albums to this point were clearly rock albums. Lumpy Gravy on the other hand started as an orchestral suite but by the time of its release veered off track to incorporate twangy surf guitars, primitive tape manipulations and a bunch of hippies under a piano mumbling stoned hippy nonsense about pigs and ponies. It's the primordial soup from which Zappa would elsewhere summon order, an exhilarating ride through elements randomly assembled and welded together with brutal jump-cuts. Again, this is one of the few early albums whose previous edition sounded fine so the lack of a remaster here is no big problem.

Unlike Cruising With Ruben And The Jets (1968) which is presented here in its controversial 1987 mix. As with Freak Out it's difficult for me to care because I always figured Ruben was a worthless exercise in nostalgia. Zappa's original sleevenotes admit as much, minus the value judgement, calling it "just a bunch of old men... sitting around the studio, mumbling about the good old days". Except where the original had been a bunch of tired twenty-something geriatrics reminiscing over the doo-wop pop of their youth for thirteen tracks of bittersweet whine, this version is one 40-year-old bloke directing a bunch of twenty-something kids in a romanticised pastiche of the same. More Shakin' Stevens than Sha Na Na, more Happy Days than American Graffiti.

In some ways Ruben represented a fond farewell to such sounds. That's not entirely accurate, of course, but it's certainly true that Zappa would never again look back at such length or with such awed reverence. From this point on retro glances would be constructive, substantial, as with the astonishingly beautiful vignettes which peppered the original Mothers final release as an active band, the double set Uncle Meat (1969). Recorded concurrently with Ruben, songs such as 'Cruising For Burgers' and 'Dog Breath' express the full range of teenage joys and frustrations with a rare mix of honesty and dignity.

But there's so much more to Uncle Meat. It's the point where Zappa finally managed to fuse the various elements from Lumpy Gravy into an ordered, accessible whole whilst reaching even further for source material. Free jazz is all over Uncle Meat, but also notable is a debut for the piquant yet distinctively musty ambience of material recorded live on stage. It's the first adequate showcase for the expanded Mothers lineup, most of whom covered a range of instruments to the point where a small orchestra could be overdubbed into existence for the airless mechanical perfection of 'Project X' and 'The Dog Breath Variations'. It's not all amazing, some of the documentary material is a bit much, but again that's only one perspective. It'd be easy enough to argue that clips such as 'Our Bizarre Relationship' are the most avant-garde inclusions here, anticipating by three decades the obscenity of modern celebrity in a networked age. It may even be true, personally I've no patience for hearing sixty seconds of Zappa's old flatmate reminiscing about the time he had two girls in one night. Worse, this is another 80s update with forty-odd extra minutes of such gibberish.

Here I have to admit that I've never actually heard the original vinyl of Uncle Meat so beyond the obviously superfluous 'bonus' tracks I can't compare. This version is decent enough, there's no fluctuating treble or any of such nonsense, but given how much better the new versions of Burnt Weeny Sandwich (1969) and Weasels Ripped My Flesh sound I can't help wonder what I'm missing. Until I heard the new Weasels I'd started to wonder if it was one of those records I'd worn out through over-exposure. And, yeah, maybe there is an element of that, it's not an album I'll play too often cos if needs be I can summon it up in my head, no electricity required. But I'm glad they got it right this time, glad it finally sounds again more like the version I imagine, pleased it's more a resurrection than a remaster.

Weasels is special because it's the sound of the original Mothers really letting go. This is the album Zappa detractors such as Penman would claim doesn't exist, a collage of mostly on-stage moments where the band truly 'plunge into the world of the Other'. Sure, there are self-conscious, precocious attempts to let us know just how clever they are, but why should that be a problem? If anything it's charming, especially the moment in 'Toads Of The Short Forest' where Zappa lectures an audience on tempo, concluding with "the tambourine playing in 3/4, and the alto sax is blowing its nose", is delivered with a playful warmth, driven by the kind of passion that makes virtuosity something to admire even for those like me who aren't much bothered about time signatures. You can hear this is the sound of people playing beyond the theoretical limits of their abilities, marvel at the fireworks without understanding the chemistry behind the explosions.

Despite being mostly, approximately, jazz of some description, Weasels is also notable for its breadth. 'My Guitar Wants To Kill Your Mama' is hard rock at its most concise, 'Directly From My Heart To You' is heavy blues with electric violin, the title track is two minutes of white noise, and 'Oh No' revises an orchestral theme from Lumpy Gravy adding a Beatles-baiting lyric more vicious and cutting than anything on We're Only In It For The Money. For once this eclecticism was actually something of a compromise, Weasels being intended as the second of two samplers for a twelve record box set. Burnt Weeny Sandwich was the first sampler, an excellent album in its own right but one which can only suffer in comparison with Weasels. Not that they're entirely similar, Weeny is the evil twin. Where Weasels takes ugly abstraction and makes it beautiful Weeny is a series of gorgeously poised themes — almost respectable — wantonly vandalised by garish discordance, bad vibrations. I'll always struggle with the lifeless doo-wop covers that bookend Weeny but elsewhere more of a balance is struck, with the characteristically propulsive 'Little House I Used To Live In' and the uncharacteristically delicate shanty 'Aybe Sea' deserving special mention.

To some, everything else is postlude. Zappa sacked the band, claiming he couldn't afford to keep paying them a retainer. He recorded the solo Hot Rats (1969) with a bunch of crack session musicians including late period Mother Ian Underwood, and featuring a guest appearance from his old friend Captain Beefheart. At the time it may have been seen as cutting edge jazz-rock, it may more accurately have been seen as hard rock with lots of long guitar solos. In either case it's enjoyable enough, civilised light refreshment after the intensity of late-period Mothers. 'Peaches In Regalia' is musical helium, impossible to absorb without feeling uplifted. Hot Rats is another album appearing here in its fully restored glory for the first time on CD.

Next, needing a group to play shows, he put together a new band he called 'The Mothers' despite retaining only himself and Underwood from the old line-up. Fronting the new band were Mark Volman and Howard Kaylan, on exile from pop group The Turtles appearing pseudonymously as Flo And Eddie, spouting aimless obscenity, revelling in the egotistical exploitative bullshit of life on the road over competent, occasionally inspired, jazz-rock. So begins the era Ray Collins referred to: the zany years.

To be fair, it's an era that would eventually produce some of Zappa's finest work, but unfortunately that's beyond the scope of this batch of re-issues. Instead, for now we end with three albums that see Zappa in steady decline. Chunga's Revenge is by far the best, if only for the majestic 'Twenty Small Cigars' and the lascivious 'Would You Go All The Way'. Filmore East, June 1971 has a few engaging instrumental fragments and a whole heap of tedious drivel, but is relatively coherent next to the inane nonsense of 'Billy The Mountain' on Just Another Band From L.A. (1972). Is it a vicious dig at his former bandmates and their money woes? Is it another satire of conservative America, the military in particular? It's hard to tell. At nearly twenty-five minutes of yadda yadda yadda with not a memorable tune or notable inflection in earshot I tend to tune out about half-way through. You can't fault his ambition, but a few moments on Absolutely Free aside Zappa did not have any notable gift for musical theatre. All three of the Flo And Eddie albums sound as spiffy here as they ever will, but Chunga's excepted that's not much of a boast.

So. Not a great place to end up, especially for an apologist, let's peddle back instead. Nobody's perfect, demonstrating that shamelessness was one of Zappa's many strengths. But it's easy to ignore the weak ones, cue up Uncle Meat or Hot Rats and focus instead on those qualities that are worth celebrating. Gleeful iconoclasm. Voracious stylistic promiscuity, a pitifully low boredom threshold. And most importantly a relentless, joyous energy. Zappa, the crusty old cynic denying the existence of love even on his first album at the grand old age of 26, clearly loved music with every ounce of his being. He loved it passionately, with a magnificent intensity that illuminates most every second of those fifty-six albums, even the crap ones. It's his defining quality, the reason why the best of his work remains powerful today.

Post-Punk Monk
Oct 8, 2012 2:11pm

Count me in with the naysayers. Actually, I'll go further than that. The music of Frank Zappa is the only such examples that I can think of that actually cause me physical discomfort. Hearing it makes me feel queasy. Admittedly, I've only heard about an album's worth en toto over my 49 years, but I've learned enough to seriously avoid it in a way that puts my almost mystical ability to avoid hearing music I know that I won't enjoy [like Lady Gaga, for instance], very much in the shade!

It's odd how I can love music like early DEVO, that seems to be issuing from a similar trajectory as FZ but I have no problems with DEVO; at least early in their career. When I hear Zappa music, it seems like it is consumed with contempt not only for its audience, but also with itself for even bothering to court said audience. It's odd. Put Frank Zappa on a Congressional dais and he's intelligent, admirable, witty, and articulate. I admired him as long as he was not making music. But his music just sounds unhealthy to me.

http://postpunkmonk.wordpress.com
For more ruminations on the Fresh New Sound of Yesterday

Reply to this Admin

Ivan T. W.
Oct 8, 2012 3:49pm

I have a lot of fond memories of Zappa, I got into him in high school and was super into his stuff when I met my first girlfriend. Incidentally, it was the CD versions I heard mostly because I didn't have a record player to compare the differences to, so I would be interested in picking up We're Only in It For The Money or Absolutely Free to see how it sounds compared to my own nostalgic recollections.

Reply to this Admin

oscar
Oct 8, 2012 4:23pm

Maybe you should read up a bit better. Both Freak Out! and Cruising With Ruben & The Jets have already been reissued from the original analog mastertapes (don't you ever heard about MOFO and Grasy Love Songs ?, please check www.zappa.com). And we hope Uncle Meat will have the same treatment too. Cheers

Reply to this Admin

Ringo P Stacey
Oct 8, 2012 6:04pm

In reply to oscar:

Thanks for reading and taking the time to comment. I know about MOFO and Greasy Love Songs, and I hope the rumours about a deluxe edition of Uncle Meat are true. I didn't mention them because the article was already quite long and I had to chop out anything outside the remit of the piece - this latest batch of reissues. Most importantly, I was trying to make them accessible to the more sceptical listener - the type of people who might chance a cheap CD from Amazon but really aren't going to care that there's an expensive 2 disc expanded version available directly from the Zappa website.

Reply to this Admin

The50somethingindiekid
Oct 8, 2012 6:45pm

Zappa like his childhood friend, Beefheart and Marmite is something of an acquired taste. I like Marmite and Beefheart but always thought Zappa as good a musician as he was was too far up his own arse to make any real sense of the world around him. Beefheart knew when to quit. Zappa never mastered that part of the music business. Me I just don't get all the hero worship but then again I suppose none of my friends understand my hero worship of the Gang of Four.

Reply to this Admin

Spacious
Oct 8, 2012 10:11pm

I'm kind of on the fence with Zappa. He is mostly a nostalgic figure for me now.

What bothers me most about his music is that many of the progressive rock acts that were clearly imitating him (Samla Mammas Manna springs immediately to mind) were able to zero in on what was wrong and improve upon it so instantly.

That having been said, I got to see him play live once and never regretted it.

Reply to this Admin

Blair
Oct 10, 2012 7:09pm

Thank you for writing this essay! Zappa gets the cold shoulder most of the time and I can understand how from a musical standpoint one may be turned off. But, to dislike him solely because he held contempt for his audience was beyond me. Granted, I know there’s more to it than just that contempt: some find him sexist, a curmudgeon, fatuous, and then there’s his alleged poor handling of royalties to his musicians. Yet, if I judged my music tastes on the personalities of the musicians or composers, I think it would be a very short list. No one stops listening to The Velvet Underground just because Lou Reed is a dick

I’m an ardent fan ever since 1995 and even though I don’t listen to him as much as I used to, I’m still happy to have all of his albums on file in case I want to listen once more. Zappa always gets maligned with the prog tag which is unfortunate because that was always the tip of the iceberg. Long story songs like “The Adventures of Greggory Peccary” or “Billy the Mountain” do fly off the rails and tend to deflate towards the end, but I think Zappa’s secret weapon are his more concise tunes. Some are such aurally pleasurable ear worms that I’ll never tire of them. I hope someone takes a look into his back catalog after reading this.

Reply to this Admin

Johnny Lobster
Oct 10, 2012 9:55pm

Zappa is either the object of fawning fanboy praise, or subject to unfair dismissal. At least your article attempted to straddle the line between the two. It might take another decade or two before Zappa is really appreciated for his truly great work.

Reply to this Admin


Oct 19, 2012 1:26pm

Any scepticism about Zappas greatness will be dispelled if you see 'The Torture Never Stops'
Zappas Halloween 1981 New York concert,it is a mesmerizing and astonishing performance,the musicianship,originality and breadth of Zappas cynicism is awesome to see
you can watch a clip here and be converted!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kv0iVPyFMaQ

Reply to this Admin

max
Oct 28, 2012 8:06pm

Just baffles the mind...first, that editors at Quietus are so Zappaphobic and then this piece misfired. I dont know where to begin but surely 'Chunga' is the weakest of the Flo & Edie period Mothers. Surely, Peaches, Little Umbrella's and It Must be Camel are the defining tracks and genre-defying triumphs of Hot Rats. (And as an aside, why do Brits frequently cite this Jazz-rock infused album as Zappa's finest?) Surely, the melodic triumphs from We're Only it For the Money (Mama, Idiot Bastard Son, Discorporate) soar above any alleged social critique present in the album. Surely, Burnt Weeny Sandwich edges out Weasels if only for Holiday in Berlin and Little House...And I agree with much of what you say, especially in regard to Uncle Meat. Thus is the nature of opinions.. but the revolutionary scale of this work and the compositional prowess in evidence -- all short-comings including Rueben and the Jets is forgiven. As a six year span of one man's work-- which excludes his oft maligned and excellent Big Band orchestrations Waka Jawaka & Grand Wazoo-- its staggering in its scope, ambition and acheivement...wrapping it it up apologetically and in 'Quietus-esque' undertones is gonna sound pithy and best and cheap at worst.

Reply to this Admin

Bob
Oct 29, 2012 12:54am

Yeah i used to be sceptic until i actually listened to his early records. I think you've just got to pick and choose the best with his vast back catalogue. I think most of his best work can be found between 1966 & 1975. I definitely recommend people who don't know Zappa to watch The Torture Never Stops recorded at one of his New York Halloween concerts in 1981, the musicianship of him and the band is amazing.

Reply to this Admin

Ben
Oct 31, 2012 4:21pm

Remastering/remixing does nothing to affect the conceptual quality of Zappa's music--which is the best.

Reply to this Admin

Ringo P
Oct 31, 2012 10:29pm

In reply to max:

Just to be clear - Waka/Jawaka and The Grand Wazoo were excluded because they're not part of this batch of re-issues, sorry if the title is misleading, the piece is supposed to cover the majority but not all of Zappa's work between '66 and '72. Also excluded are 200 Motels, Mothermania, and a bunch of archival stuff that's emerged since the late 80s.

I agree with you wholeheartedly about forgiving Zappa his shortcomings!

Reply to this Admin

Don Each
Nov 7, 2012 7:06pm

I appreciate it all. But Studio Tan and Joe's Garage might be my favorites. And Waka Jawaka.

Reply to this Admin

Alex
Dec 11, 2012 10:26pm

The unfortunate side-effect of Zappa releasing so much material is that people are unfairly hard on each individual release, as if it must be an above average Zappa release for it to be worth listening to. I honestly feel like most of these 12 releases are above average for pop music being released at the time, period, so it's hard for me to imagine dismissing any of them completely, save for maybe Ruben. I also find it ludicrous to laud so much praise for Absolutely Free and pan both Freak Out! and WOIIFTM. I can't really imagine any without the other two, as they present multiple sides of the same idea, and I feel like Absolutely Free is the lightest in content musically and lyrically, the most obvious satirically, and the most grating with regards to recording quality. By comparison, Freak Out! and WOIIFTM sound revolutionary, fierce, strange, and unapologetic.

Reply to this Admin