The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website


Marina & The Diamonds
Electra Heart Emily Mackay , May 1st, 2012 06:20

Add your comment »

The titles alone cause almost physical pain. 'Primadonna' bodes awfulness. The self-aware self-obsession, the nod to Madonna in a year that she herself releases an album called MDNA (because what is it to be a female icon? I'm just worried that no one's really spent enough pop-hours pondering this question). Or Electra Heart itself, with its deathly boring promise of daddy issues.

But to give Marina Diamandis her credit, that was supposed to be the point. In a great early interview on this album with Popjustice's Peter Robinson she clarified that Electra Heart wasn't so much an alter ego as a shadow self; all the worst parts of Marina Diamandis that she didn't want to become.

The idea, and the initial two-song taster of 'Fear And Loathing', the dark Tori Amos-esque track that closes this album and then the giddy, chart-hungry 'Radioactive' boded well for something interesting (even if the mirror gazing haircut/nervous breakdown video for the former should have rung warning bells). A Marina exploring her own defects and difficulties at the same tame as making the most of herself with all the resources available to her could be great. But, as Robinson noted at the time 'I'm playing a character that embodies everything shallow and awful I don't want to be' also offers a whole lot of get-out clause.

By the release of third video 'The Archetypes', the EH concept wasn't looking so healthy, with Marina pouting and swaying, blonde, vacant and Del Rey-ish into the camera as a Speak And Spell voice opined "Electra Heart, are you for real? / For others, we become ourselves... the archetypes." Mmm. And what are those archetypes?

"Housewife. Beauty Queen. Homewrecker. Idle Teen". Um, speak for yourself? I mean, fucking hell, seriously? This is all you've got? The teenage Manic fan's obsession with the iconicity Marilyn Monroe, the Desperate Housewives-style decades-late debunking of wholesome Stepford-wife femininity, tired retreads of Hole's 'Celebrity Skin' and your own 'Hollywood', a bloody song actually called 'The Valley Of The Dolls'?

Still, a shonky concept could be quietly ignored, surely, the tunes being good enough? There's been some fretting about her selling out her individuality to big-name producers, but it's worth remembering that Greg Kurstin and Biff Stannard made appearances on The Family Jewels, and she's never made a secret of her huge pop ambitions. Played right, the presence of Dr Luke and Stargate could have been the engine room that Marina piloted to the heights she's always craved.

And so it was: well, kinda. The Dr Luke-produced 'Primadonna', her biggest ever hit, is decent enough. No faceless banger; it's certainly got more life and thought behind it than similar womping efforts on the Madonna or Nicki Minaj albums, but just doesn't give enough back for its supreme lyrical irritations. The problem here isn't Dr Luke smothering Marina's idiosyncracies so much as Marina/Electra herself crafting them into something paper-thin and paper-cut annoying. "You say that I'm kinda difficult but it's always someone else's fault... Got you wrapped around my finger babe / You can count on me to misbehave... I know I've got a big ego I don't know why it's such a big deal though." Both title and lyrics of 'Bubblegum Bitch', too, are cringeworthy, with all the vapidity promised but little in the way of analysis thereof, though it's a passable bit of Katy Perryish stomp that retains some of her Sparksy, camp oddness. Marina's powerful voice is what carries most of this album, and allows you at first to overlook lines like "I think I want your American Tan / I think you're gonna be my biggest fan". But she just won't either let Electra Heart lie or give you enough of her to make you care; Electra's neither a character nor an alter ego nor a monster; she's an idly drawn doodle.

And if Marina's just dressing up as this narcisstic tosser, like the sexy witch at a Halloween party, she never once lets slip anything that might be genuinely raw or ugly, just that sort of 'oh how sad, my mascara's been still-attractively smeared down my face by my lonely, damaged tears' sort of vibe. Or as she puts it by the camp, Girls Aloudish bounce-and-blart of 'Homewrecker' between excruciating spoken word passsages, by which point it's all getting a little much to swallow, "I guess you'd say that my life's a mess but I'm still looking pretty in this dress".

It's not like self-loving and loathing, fame and identity aren't common enough obsessions in pop. Take Kanye West's My Dark Twisted Fantasy, a platinum-plated ego trip if ever there was one. Yet for all its vicariously enjoyable Pharaonic braggadocio, it was seasoned with feelings of genuine self-disgust, weariness, remorse and self-deprecating humour. All Electra and her supposed deconstruction of American idolatry really seems to be telling us here is that being pretty and famous isn't all it's cracked up to be, and that some days, she's just not entirely convinced she's amazing. I know, my heart's spasming too.

Disappointingly for someone who has the potential to be such a fearsome pop star, the lack of distance between Electra's vapidity and Marina's presence in the more upbeat tracks means that the ballads are much more successful, the moments of vulnerability in the likes of 'Lies' with its stately, dark R&B shimmer and cry of "I just want it to be perfect / To believe it's all been worth the fight", 'The Living Dead''s crisp Gaga-meets-Eurthymics heartbroken-zombie lament or 'Fear And Loathing' allowing some connection where 'Primadonna' and 'Bubblegum Bitch' don't. Not so much 'Starring Role' which equates a breaking down relationship to an unsatisfactory casting and manages to rhyme 'Starring Role' with, er, "supporting role". It's a shame 'Radioactive' wasn't included – it at least had some of the dangerous rush of a crush, the puns ("I'm heading for a meltdown") not obscuring its stardust sparkle.

By the time of 'The State Of Dreaming' what theme there is is more exhausted than a wannabe actress exhausted from a double-shift at the diner and the strip club. The likes of 'Power & Control''s weak electropop and 'Teen Idle''s choral Madonnaism with references to bottle-blondes, cheerleader chants, and "blood and guts and chocolate cake" and "21st century whores" is a fine example of the problems of describing your concept rather than showing it. Over over and over and over a-bloody-gain. "I wish I wasn't such a narcissist / I wish I didn't really kiss the mirror when on my own / Oh man I'm gonna die alone", Marina whispers in the latter. Maybe a little less time for both her and Electra gazing into the glass, and more finding her way out of her own ass, and her career won't have to.

If you love our features, news and reviews, please support what we do with a one-off or regular donation. Year-on-year, our corporate advertising is down by around 90% - a figure that threatens to sink The Quietus. Hit this link to find out more and keep on Black Sky Thinking.

Air Run
May 1, 2012 7:45pm

This review was very well written. It's great to read a critique that explains WHY the writer doesn't like the music. You said most everything that I thought while listening to this album. I had to roll my eyes when I heard that the subject matter was going to be "sex and feminism". How... edgy?

I would not call myself a "diamond" (as her fans call themselves - or she calls them?) but I do enjoy what she creates from time to time. Musically, I love her stuff. She has a fantastic voice and can put together some brilliant melodies with a refreshing take on conventional pop chord changes. It's the lyrics the ruin the songs for me a lot of the time.

It's just too easy to do the "look at me judge/imitate the fake people ironically" thing (even if the person is yourself). It's like one of those annoying teenage girls (guys, too if we're honest) with a Tumblr account came up with the concept. You know, those people with 1,000+ followers and all they do is re-blog other people's "vintage" photos of half dressed, underfed models, or coffee, or people smoking, or lame quotes. What are they trying to say? Are they approving? Disapproving? The irony is blurred (if there is any) and most of the time it is completely erased. The person criticizing the fakeness becomes fake themselves.

Reply to this Admin

May 2, 2012 2:58pm

as harsh as this review is, it's refreshing to read a critic who has in fact listened to all the music and understands the concept of it, enough to write about all of the plot holes and shortcomings it has, instead of simply dismissing marina because she changed her sound. too many of the poor reviews were just pressed that she didn't make a "the family jewels" 2.

Reply to this Admin

rosie lord
May 2, 2012 3:54pm

I agree with most of what's said here, and i'm not a fan of the album, but this is a little unnecessarily mean in places.

Reply to this Admin

Neil McNab
May 2, 2012 6:15pm

I mean to say "I am Marina and you are the diamonds" is what she says to her audience! No wonder they bought so few tickets to her tour that she had to call it off.

Reply to this Admin

May 2, 2012 7:43pm

Harsh review, but at least a well-written one. At least the author actually took the time to listen to the music and dissect it in order to give a proper, honest review, which is a lot more than what most so-called music journalists are doing these days. Though I would've appreciated it if he gave his opinion on "Valley of The Dolls" instead of just dismissing it because of its title. But as much as I love the album, I won't lie and say it is without its flaws. I don't think it's bad, I just think Marina's mistake was presenting it as a concept album when it doesn't really fit the mold of a concept album (each song tells a separate story, but the album as a whole doesn't). I guess that's why most reviewers are viewing the album as a joke instead of a solid pop record.

@ Neil McNab:

She postponed her tour due to vocal problems, which she's been struggling with for weeks now. Not because no one's coming to her shows. Might help to actually verify what you're talking about before sprouting untruths.

Reply to this Admin

Joseph Coward
May 9, 2012 12:34pm

When will the narcissistic pop star fad for inventing ill-conceived alter egos end? Also, that Robinson interview with her was funny; do you think Marina had recently learned the word 'antithesis'?

Reply to this Admin

Jun 10, 2012 5:37am

In reply to Air Run:

The whole idea, I don't think you or the author of this article understand, is that SHE IS temporarily what she seeks to criticize (the materialistic fakes and the degenerate youth of today) to blatantly and explicitly mock them. I am trying my best to agree with your opinion on her lyricism, but I simply cannot. She has received worse critical reception than the likes of Gaga with "Born This Way" which lyrics were redundantI, unintentionally tacky and pretentious. She goes NOWHERE CLOSE to the lyrics Marina has managed to produce - and Gaga has more writers working on her tracks than Marina does.

Like it or not or whether or not you can relate to her lyrics, they are undoubtedly remarkably philosophical. She has her typical ballads like "Starring Role" and "Lies", but even they have some spark of depth in them Beyoncé makes ENTIRE ALBUMS of tracks with typical, mediocre lyrics, yet she has never once had critical reception this horribly.

It is PLAIN CLEAR to anyone with objectivity reading this that you and the author and anyone else that has bashed the album's concept simply do not get it. This is evident in his unending crucification of "Teen Idle"'s lyrics - she gets flamed for "having her head up her ass", when that is entirely the concept and message she wanted to convey in the song.

And then, "Electra Heart" is thrown shade at. Really? Does it really require so much deliberation to figure out what Electra is so as to bash her type of existence? She is clearly an artistic character - a role that Marina is playing throughout this entire album (except for "Buy The Stars").  Gaga - who got a 71 for Born This Way - plays a role MULTIPLE TIMES in her most recent album. Lana Del Rey - who got a 61 - has, too, been bashed for her playing a character other than herself in "Born To Die", even when she has not confirmed the existence of such character herself. 

Reply to this Admin

Jun 12, 2012 1:13pm

In reply to Berns:

you are so, so wrong.

Reply to this Admin

Aug 9, 2013 12:09am

You obviously don't understand the whole point if Electra heart. Marina is very clever and this album is one of the best ones I've heard of.

Reply to this Admin

Mar 20, 2014 8:15am

To be honest Marina's music is better than any of todays music.

Reply to this Admin

Apr 3, 2014 6:34am

She's an amazing artist to some people who feel or have these issues in life so u can call her a ego maniac umm ok u don't understand the music or better or her u don't understand

Reply to this Admin