The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website

Three Songs No Flash

Banging The Door: John Lydon Reclaims His Irish Identity
Mic Wright , October 14th, 2010 04:46

Mic Wright reflects on PiL's performance at the Electric Picnic earlier this summer, and sees John Lydon exorcising his difficult history with Ireland and the Catholic church

Add your comment »

John Lydon has a long memory. On October 6 1980, he was thrown into a cell at Mountjoy prison after an altercation with the Garda at the Horse & Tram pub. It kept him off Irish stages for over 20 years and directly influenced the Public Image Limited album that followed it, Flowers of Romance.

To the son of Irish immigrants, the incident felt like rejection by his homeland. He recounted the events again bitterly in an Irish Times interview earlier this year: “I went to a pub and the barman wouldn’t serve me. Words were exchanged and the police were called. I was arrested for attacking a policeman’s fist with my face and thrown in Mountjoy for the night. Some homecoming. The police and the screws made a big deal out of me, they tried to shatter my morale – well, good luck on that one.”

Lydon channelled his rage and the uneasy atmosphere in PiL following the departure of Jah Wobble into Flowers of Romance. He told the Culture Show: “I didn’t even wait for the band to get into the studio. I had to get this anger out of me.” Lydon’s rage and paranoia is suffused in every note of the record and his imprisonment in Mountjoy is explicitly referenced on ‘Francis Massacre’. On the clattering, almost-Vaudevillian track, Lydon wails that “he will not plead guilty” but “go down for life”. No one could suggest he lacks a flair for drama.

But the effect of the 1980 incident was real enough and kept Lydon from returning to Ireland until The Sex Pistols played Electric Picnic in 2008 as part of the Combine Harvester Tour, a cash-generating jaunt around the European festival circuit (a Dublin date on the 1996 Filthy Lucre tour was cancelled).

This year’s performance at the same festival with PiL was an entirely different beast, more than a money making endeavour – Lydon claims the tour might lose him money and is being bankrolled by his Country Life butter ad cash – it felt like something more personal. While The Sex Pistols picked at the scab of English culture and identity, Lydon’s lyrics with PiL often plunge deep into the wounds of Irish history and his own difficult relationship with his homeland.

Near the end of PiL’s Electric Picnic set, Lydon acknowledged the difference between reprising his faux-villainous Richard III role as Johnny Rotten in The Sex Pistols and playing the more personal Public Image material: “You’ve made me feel very welcome. I don’t with the Pistols but I do with PiL.”

But as comfortable as he seemed by the end of the set, there was no question that PiL’s Irish excursion was both a homecoming and a settling of scores. In his The Telegraph: “My mother died from cancer, it was an excruciating death. And the priest was in no rush to come over from Ireland to give her the Last Rites in hospital. The opposite in fact. He took his time and missed the boat. My mum was dying and she was clinging to any straw… he never arrived.”

He also articulates a sense of disgust that the Church should judge him while concealing the crimes of priests. He told the Irish Times: “When my younger brother Martin was being confirmed, he wanted me as his sponsor. The church refused outright. They couldn’t have the anti-Christ Johnny Rotten walk down the aisle. How dare they make a moral judgment on me.” But the Church wasn’t alone. The Irish establishment long viewed Lydon with suspicion. Government documents released in 2008 revealed that The Sex Pistols were investigated by the Garda as “a threat to Irish morals”.

During PiL’s set, it feels as if Lydon is restating his pride in his Irishness. During 'Warrior', he puts new emphasis on the lyrics (“I am a warrior and this is MY land…”) and throws himself into a rousing rendition of 'Rise' which provides the set’s only true singalong moment. By the end he’s smiling and applauding the crowd, the curmudgeonly mask slipping slightly.

In his autobiography, the appropriately named Rotten: No Blacks, No Irish, No Dogs, Lydon says: “It’s no accident that the Irish invented stream-of-consciousness literature. It was of absolute necessity. Poverty and deprivation of their own language made this very important. Hence long-term memory, which is a Celtic thing.” After this performance, he can replace the memory of a Mountjoy prison cell with a better one: PiL onstage in Stradbally.


If you love our features, news and reviews, please support what we do with a one-off or regular donation. Year-on-year, our corporate advertising is down by around 90% - a figure that threatens to sink The Quietus. Hit this link to find out more and keep on Black Sky Thinking.

uncle d
Oct 14, 2010 10:39am

I love the way he expects us to believe the butter ad was to fund the PIL shows, not all that lovely money from promoters paying in advance on a sold out tour, oh no, it was the butter advert, yeah right.....

Reply to this Admin

Oct 14, 2010 12:53pm

Did he mention why the Sex Pistols decorated the stage with Union Jacks at EP 2008? Quite the "homecoming" gambit. The homophobic abuse to the guy in the crowd was a treat too. They were boo'd off the stage amid a general feeling of disgust from the crowd, and he seemed furious. Whole thing was a shambles.

Reply to this Admin

Mic Wright
Oct 14, 2010 2:37pm

In reply to Mo:

Funnily enough he skipped that. I always have the feeling his gooning around with (often dodgy) British imagery in The Sex Pistols and then playing on the Irishness with PIL.

Reply to this Admin

Oct 14, 2010 9:24pm

Sorry, can't quite buy Mr. Lydon as victim after his racist shenanigans in Barcelona two years ago.

Reply to this Admin

Oct 15, 2010 10:54am

In reply to uncle d:

The butter money funded the restart of PIL ( paying band members, instruments, rehearsal room, hotels, petrol, plane tickets to get to usa etc etc) & the shows on the Pil tour were NOT sold out. As for PIL the band there isn't another band out there at the moment that offer such variety & intense a body of work.

Reply to this Admin

Oct 15, 2010 2:57pm

'And the priest was in no rush to come over from Ireland to give her the Last Rites in hospital.'

They don't have Catholic priests in Finsbury Park?

Also: Ireland's not John Lydon's 'homeland'. It's his parents' homeland. Ditto Kevin Rowland. 'My National Pride'? Can't help noticing you don't actually live there, Kev.

Reply to this Admin

Oct 16, 2010 1:24am

In reply to Jones:

John Lydon 'became' Irish when he wrote his autobiography. It was still trendy to be 'Celtic' at this time. Similarly his love of Arsenal and football in general. I'm London Irish too but consider myself a Londoner first and foremost. Shane Macgowan's a big tart in this respect as well. Any interview before around 1988 has him speaking as the cockney's cockney. As Orwell said:

"It's easy to be patriotic about other people's countries"

Reply to this Admin

An Irishman Writes
Oct 18, 2010 9:33am

I'm sticking up for Johnny here.
As a son of the Irish republic I'm happy to claim Lydon, Rowland, McGowan and others as our own.
They're Britains own as well. You can be both.
John Lydon admitting to confusion and divided loyalty over his roots is a lot truer to how a lot of people feel about their backgrounds than any number of well-meaning " Hey! Let's celebrate diversity " projects will allow.
It's not always about celebration and it's not just about where you grew up. It's complicated as most important things are.

Reply to this Admin

Aug 4, 2013 1:00am

up laois

Reply to this Admin

Johnny Kowalski
May 18, 2015 5:12pm

I was lucky enough to be at both the Pistols'Electric Picnic set and one of the first sets the reformed PIL played at the birmingham academy. The difference between the two was seismic. The former felt like mildly amusing cabaret that I could only tolerate for half an hour or so, the latter was like having the inside of my brain played back to me at one of the most stressful periods of my life. Yeah he's done some daft stuff, who hasn't? (I'm willing to bet that he finds the whole fuss about the butter ad hilarious). The modern PIL live experience is a genuinely unique thing, long may it continue.

Reply to this Admin