KatyBPhotography.co.uk" />

The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website

A Quietus Interview

The Rockin' Vicar: Rev Mann Speaks About Stryper, Slayer And Satan
Joel McIver , September 2nd, 2010 08:25

Son of metal Joel McIver meets Lady Of The Cloth Rachel Mann who has decreed: listen to metal! Amen, say we... Photographs of Rev. Mann by KatyBPhotography.co.uk

Add your comment »

The Church of England clergy are not known for their fondness for heavy music, or indeed their willingness to discuss the subject in the public forum, but Manchester-based vicar Rachel Mann made national headlines this week thanks to her comments on that very subject. Writing in the Church Times, the reverend explained that in her view Christians could learn a lot from heavy metal and that its “liberative theology of darkness” offers a new and valuable perspective. A poet, historian, musician and priest-in-charge of St. Nicholas’s, a church in Burnage, Rachel clearly has both a refreshing viewpoint of matters spiritual and the courage to express it. Could this be the moment where heavy metal and God finally gain some mutual respect? The Quietus asked the frankly ace Reverend Mann to explain…

Which metal bands are you into, Rachel?

Rachel Mann: Where do we start? Let’s go back to the classics. Of the Big Four of thrash, I especially love Metallica. I also love Slayer. My all-time love affair, which started on the Piece Of Mind tour in 1984, is Iron Maiden. Of the more recent stuff, I like Tool and Mastodon. System Of A Down are fantastic. I also love music that brings a smile to my face, like Turisas. How can you not love a metal band that has an accordion player? How cool is that? And Bigelf, who aren’t necessarily metal but they’re the love child of Deep Purple and Metallica. And there’s lots of stuff in between.

You play guitar and sing in a band called Kingdom Of The Blind. What sort of music do you play?

RM: There was one band called Sick Vicar – ha ha ha! – and another one called Corrosion, and they shared a couple of members, so when those bands stopped, Kingdom Of The Blind emerged. We’re writing stuff at the moment. We’re mixing bits of Tool and Metallica, punk and even Jethro Tull, believe it or not.

Are you into Christian metal?

RM: I’m not a huge fan, because Stryper came along in the 80s and just made me weep. They were desperate. There are Christians active in metal bands; Nicko McBrain of Iron Maiden, for example, but I’m uncomfortable with any style of music where there’s a preaching agenda and it’s about conversion. Stryper were using metal as a vehicle for the gospel, and that doesn’t interest me. I saw on the Metal Hammer feed on Facebook that there is a metalcore band called Underoath, and I noticed in the comments that a lot of people were basically saying "Eff off, Christians" and that others were saying, "This is just crap music" – and for me, the priority is the quality of the music.

How did you come to write your much-quoted article on metal and Christianity in the Church Times?

RM: I’m a writer on various religious stuff – generally much too dull to be of interest to the world! – and I’m a military historian as well. I’m also the poet-in-residence at Manchester Cathedral. But I have a huge love of rock music, and metal in particular, and I was at Sonisphere this year and I thought, ‘This needs to be commented on’. The Church Of England, with all its stuff about sexuality and bishops, has got too serious, and it needs something to wake it up – and for me, metal is one of those things that wake us up. It brings a smile to our faces, and it can also teach us some interesting things.

What, specifically, can Christians learn from heavy metal?

RM: My original phrase in the Church Times article was that there is a serious gospel lesson to be learned. It’s partly about the power of darkness. What can happen in Christianity’s Protestant wing – although the Catholics do it as well – is that it gets a bit obsessed with personal holiness. That can bring with it a certain kind of seriousness and sobriety and a condemnatory attitude, whereas life is not all about the light. You’ve got to recognise the dark: maybe that’s also a place where people can learn and grow from. I don’t want to get too pompous about it, but for me the Christian faith is all about wholeness. It’s about being a human being, not just being holy, and to be a proper human being you’ve got to have light and shade. Metal is not afraid of the dark, whereas most Christians are afraid of the dark. Not all, but most.

Doesn’t The Bible tell its readers to avoid the dark side at all costs?

RM: Yes, but The Bible is not a consistent book. I don’t trust Christians who tell you that there aren’t contradictions in The Bible. The Bible also tells you that God is found in the dark as well as the light: Psalm 139 says that there is no place you can go to where there isn’t God. But certain sorts of Christianity, which are obsessed with holiness and purity, will say, "No, you can’t go there" – and they will draw out, particularly from the writings of Paul, evidence of that. But Jesus wasn’t afraid of the dark. He wasn’t afraid to sit with people who society condemned. In fact, he was an outsider, and that’s the reason he got nailed up, in my view. Respectable people couldn’t handle the fact that this guy was saying, "Accept people for who they are". People can use The Bible for anything, as any of us who have ever stood on a doorstep while a Jehovah’s Witness quotes it at us will know.

The Church Of Satan states that man is an animal, and that he can only be true to himself if he acknowledges and embraces his animal side. Is that a reasonable view?

RM: Well, you have to remember that the Church Of Satan has a huge element of theatre. A better example is evolution: you’ll find some Christians saying that it didn’t happen. Now, I believe in evolution, and if it’s true then we are animals, and we have to be honest and real about sex and gender. I had a friend who is a Wiccan, and for him sex seemed to be a way of life. I’m a bit more conservative than that, but recognising our animal and sexual dimension has got to be part of being a full human being. Any tradition within the Christian faith – or any faith – which says that we have to cut off our passions has got to be misguided.

How controversial are your views within the Christian community?

RM: I know that I stand at the liberal to radical end. Theologically, I come from a feminist perspective, which is not the standard position of most people in the church, but it is a respected position. I’m lucky in that I’m based in a city which is not only liberal but socially progressive as well. My priorities are more to do with working with the poor and trying to bring a modicum of peace to the world: those are the important things to me, not getting hung up on what people do with their private lives. The message that I seek to preach is one of inclusion, love and respect: it’s about people using their own brains to think.

Surely the definition of a church is diametrically opposed to independent thinking: it’s a place where people voluntarily think as one?

RM: You’re always caught in a bind in any organisational context, and I don’t think this is a religious thing as such, it’s to do with human institutions and society. Inevitably, in inviting people to want to think for themselves, and work things out for themselves, you’re offering advice and guidance. The question is, where is the leeway and where is the freedom? We all have a sense of where we draw the line. I want people to use their intelligence and their discretion and their judgment as much as possible, because at its extremes, religion can be a bit cultish and seek to control people’s perspectives, and I can’t bear that.

What do you make of the Westboro Baptist Church, who picketed Ronnie James Dio’s funeral in order to air their views about all gay people going to hell?

RM: If they’re right, I don’t want to go to their heaven. Their whole agenda has gone beyond religious conservatism into psychopathic self-hate. They just hate human beings: there’s a total lack of humanity and respect there. Lunatics. There’s about 60 members and they all belong to one family: it’s terrifying.

Are there any similarly deranged church groups in the UK?

RM: “Not that I’m aware of, although there is Christian Voice, which is led by a guy called Stephen Green who seems to me to be primarily fixated on sexuality. He famously tried to organise a picket of Jerry Springer: The Musical because it was offensive to Christianity. I don’t think the guy had even seen it. It was like a throwback to the Pythons and The Life Of Brian, which was condemned for being blasphemous. It’s one of the finest critiques of religion, and a very intelligent work about human delusion. I’m so embarrassed about that. But that’s what can happen in churches: people want to react instead of thinking. The problem with Christian Voice, who represent a very small minority of conservative, evangelical Christians, is that they have a huge voice, which means that they get represented as the mainstream Christian perspective.

The clergy don’t usually go on the record to espouse heavy metal. Why are you in such a minority?

RM: Part of the answer lies in the fact that people in the clerical profession are largely from a middle-class background. I grew up in a working-class home in the West Midlands, which is a metal heartland. In my opinion, the Church of England still remains the church of privilege, and its clergy reflect that fact. I’m not saying that any of that means that you can’t like AC/DC, of course.

Surely metal is middle-class music these days?

RM: I’ve also come to feel that. I think it’s shifted, but in its origins metal was about people trying to escape the trap of industrial Britain. In my case, I grew up in a Christian household, but in my teenage years I rejected God enormously and metal was part of that rejection.

So where does metal become offensive? Presumably you’re not troubled by the line "Satan laughing spreads his wings" in Black Sabbath’s ‘War Pigs’?

RM: No. For me, it’s partly about the theatre and partly about poetry. People write fiction to tell the truth, and you can make a serious point about something without necessarily being factual. With lyrics, as with a play or a film, you can tell human truths.

Norwegian black metal is founded on blasphemy. Do you like any of it?

RM: It’s not something which floats my boat, partly because the vocals don’t thrill me. I grew up listening to Ronnie James Dio and Bruce Dickinson. For me, black metal is just another step in music’s development. All interesting arts such as music push at the edges, and black metal is one of the ways in which a bunch of artists do that.

So where do we draw the line?

RM: There are one or two bands who consciously cultivate a Satanic image and make it their fundamental agenda, and that’s not for me, but I don’t want to say that people shouldn’t listen to it. Here’s an example: I really like Slayer, especially as a live band. They are awesome: they turn your insides to paté. Tom Araya is perhaps my favourite frontman ever. Now, I was listening to them in 1985, and people might have said to me as a teenager, "Stop listening to that". And yet here I am at 40, and I’m an ordained minister in the Christian religion: it hasn’t turned me into some sort of shabby human being. So I don’t want to exclude things: I’m not into censorship.

If a parent from your congregation came up to you and said, "Rachel, I’m worried because I heard my son listening to ‘Fuck Your God’ by Deicide the other day", what would you say?

RM: Ha ha! Things like that do happen occasionally. But telling people that they’ve got to stop doing something often pushes them further into it. I would hope that in most cases, people would be mature enough so that you could discuss the pros and cons in that situation.

But if that person asked you if that song title was acceptable, what would your answer be?

RM: “Well, you have to ask people what their priorities are. There was a Christian festival called Spring Harvest not long ago and a really respected speaker got up to speak in front of five or six thousand people. His opening line was "Don’t you think our faith is a complete fucking waste of time?" or words to that effect. As you can imagine, people started to shout at him and walk out, at which point he said "Why is it that you are getting so angry about me using a swear word, when a lot of people have died through poverty since I started this talk?" So if someone is offended by lyrics or swearing, I like to say – in the kindest possible way, because I don’t want to preach at them – "Here are some things to think about that might show you the way through this.”

Is it the case for someone in your job, who witnesses large amounts of suffering and misery on a daily basis, that these issues are pretty trivial?

RM: Yes: these things aren’t huge priorities for me. You know, helping somebody who has lost their baby tragically, or who is dealing with bereavement or unemployment or depression, is much more important – as is celebrating times of joy. In my work I’ve met a number of people who are living a life in hell, in a sense, which has often been imposed on them, sometimes through religion and often through the abuse of power. To lump heavy metal in with that is a joke.

What are your views on the afterlife?

RM: “I don’t believe in the existence of Satan or the existence of hell. I can’t bring myself to believe in a God who would condemn people to hell. I’ve had a very strong experience of God in my life, and I can’t believe that he gives up on people at the end of this life. I also can’t bring myself to believe in heaven in the sentimentalised, Hollywood sense. Anyone who tells you what heaven is like is selling you snake oil. But I do believe that we journey on into God’s greater love.

Surely some of your parishioners will find that view hard to grasp, coming from their local vicar?

RM: Well, maybe. In any congregation there is a range of ages, and some people have black-and-white faiths. But they know me here: I’ve been here for a number of years and they know my views. Most of them have seen me perform with my band and sing songs like ‘War Pigs’, and they live with it because they see beyond that stuff. People respond if you show them love and respect, and that’s what I try to do.


If you love our features, news and reviews, please support what we do with a one-off or regular donation. Year-on-year, our corporate advertising is down by around 90% - a figure that threatens to sink The Quietus. Hit this link to find out more and keep on Black Sky Thinking.

Sep 2, 2010 12:53pm

Totally agree with this. Just one thing I want to add, often when Satan is used its actually a metaphor, like in war pigs, its aout how war feeds the evil, so Satan enjoys the war and only strengthens his grip. But yeah, really happy to see there are some Christian Ministers who understand that metal is actually good, Personally I see it closer to the light than the darkness, even if thats how people normally see it.

Reply to this Admin

Tim Chipping
Sep 2, 2010 1:38pm

My parents were at that Spring Harvest seminar (while I was listening to Christian pop music elsewhere at the festival).

The preacher I think she's referring to is Tony Campolo. His actual quote was the slightly milder: "While you were sleeping last night, 30,000 kids died of starvation or diseases related to malnutrition. Second, most of you don't give a shit. What's worse is that you're more upset with the fact that I said shit than the fact that 30,000 kids died last night."

He's also responsible for: "I've always been skeptical of those television healers who are bald. I mean, if I had that gift, that would be the first thing I'd fix."

My mum used to play his tapes in the car a lot. He's pretty funny. His wife is now a campaigner for gay equality in the church.

Reply to this Admin

Sep 2, 2010 1:51pm

Hmm. Unconvincing.

Reply to this Admin

Rachel Mann
Sep 2, 2010 1:52pm

In reply to Tim Chipping:

Thanks for clarifying that. I knew I'd overstated the case!!

Reply to this Admin

Sep 2, 2010 2:16pm

Good stuff. Sounds like an intelligent and caring lady.
She's wrong, of course, but ...

Reply to this Admin

Sep 2, 2010 4:19pm

I can't stand metal, but this is a great article. Exactly the sort of left-of-centre analysis I would want TQ to cover.

Reply to this Admin

Sep 2, 2010 4:47pm

Great article, really interesting read and some intelligent insights here.

Reply to this Admin

Sep 3, 2010 8:12pm

I wish we had more people like you in the States. I left church because I got tired of the hypocrisy. Most of my friends are athiests and Satanists, and they are some of the most kind, caring people that I know. I love metal, much of the classic stuff like Dio, Sabbath, Rainbow, Deep Purple, Iron Maiden, and so forth is what I was raised with. At any rate, I became really involved with a church and started teaching the Jr. High bible class. I fell in love with these kids, who honestly just needed someone to talk to and not judge them and jump the gun on questions or concerns that they had. I had one girl ask me about drugs because she was considering trying it, and I told her of my own experience in experimenting and how it was not worth it. I didn't tell her to say no, I told her to really think about it, and that more often than not it leads to negative things. So I got in trouble for that. In a later class, the kids asked me how I knew there was a God because they weren't sure. I said although the bible is a great piece of literature and an integral part of Christianity, I simply said that you don't find faith in the bible. Faith is something that is found and developed over time, through life experiences. I am more sure now of my belief in the divine than I was when I was 13. Well, needless to say telling kids to think for themselves was something this church just wasn't fond of. We are all broken people and I don't see the need in pretending to be perfect at church and hide behind a congregation, a liturgy, a pulpit, and hymnals. I think so many people have forgotten to love, and have had the whole idea of Jesus being on Earth completely wrong. He was not holed up in temple being pious and only hanging with others with like minded agendas. He made a point of being with the people who were shunned and looked down upon; people who were different. I love God with all my heart and only he knows what really happens when we die. The only truth we know is we are born and we die and after that it's God's will, not my own, and no one else can judge me.

"I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ."--Mohandas Gandhi

Reply to this Admin

Sep 3, 2010 8:27pm

Yes, this is interesting and more thoughtful than the initially rather sixth-form premise suggested ('ooh look - a VICAR who likes HEAVY METAL!'). Must pick up on one point, though - the suggestion that the clergy tend to avoid metal because they're predominantly middle-class. In my experience, a majority of metal fans, myself included, have middle-class backgrounds (and indeed this piece brings to mind an old school friend who was the son of a vicar and who introduced me to Massacre... ah, happy times). Metal is an ideal form of safe rebellion and it really can't be said to be a bastion of working-class grit ever since 'Led Zeppelin I'.

Realistically, and with all respect, come on, vicars aren't into metal as a rule because it is essentially the sound of a man SCREAMING at the TOP OF HIS VOICE that everything they believe is nonsense, hypocritical and/or positively harmful to society. It would be like me recording that nutty bloke in town who bellows endlessly about how I'm for some reason going to hell and playing it over and over to myself in an endless loop. Surely? No?

Reply to this Admin

Joel McIver
Sep 4, 2010 11:40am

In reply to H-BOMB:

Massacre ruled!

Reply to this Admin

Sep 4, 2010 5:30pm

Dear Rachell,
Heavy metal is all about heaven and hell. So is our life. That is why we are totally on your side. You are a great example of the proverb which says 'Practice what you preach'. Rock on!
Dio Fan Club (Russia)

Reply to this Admin

A Believer in Jesus Christ
Apr 8, 2011 9:09am

This lady has manfactured her own 'Christianity' it bears no resemblence to The Word of God, this liberal and blasphemous portrayal of the Christian faith is indeed one more sign that The Lord's return is not far off. Repent of your evil ways while there is still time, praise God for Christian Voice and those who are willing to stand up for Jesus against the tide. Such people as Rev Mann would be putty in the hands of the Antichrist if they are here when he manifests (they are already serving him), the church of England is dead in its sins but God is not mocked as many will surely find out, unfortunately in a place of eternal torment. As for the 'spirit of life festival' in Manchester, I don't think they should be hailing the performance of a fire breathing vicar but rather cowering in trepidation at the wrath of God,'the fear of The Lord is the beginning of wisdom'.

Reply to this Admin

Tania R
Nov 16, 2011 10:42pm

In reply to A Believer in Jesus Christ:

And the above suggests eloquently the crazed judgemental ramblings of people that give real 'Christ'ians a bad name! Go out with your plackards and keep quiet elsewhere as I wouldn't want people to think 'we' were all alike! And I'm a trainee minister btw....anf a goth metal fan....a jazz fan...hay a MUSIC fan!!!

Reply to this Admin

Mar 29, 2012 8:23pm

In reply to A Believer in Jesus Christ:

Ah bugger...right after all that debate stayed thought-provoking and rational.

Tough crowd - Rock on Vicar!

Reply to this Admin

just one thing
Jan 10, 2013 12:00pm

Oh Rachel. I was with you up until the part where you said you don't believe in the existence of Satan or hell. Convincing Christians he doesn't exist is the best and most oft-used weapon the enemy has. Don't you know that God does not condemn anyone to hell? He gave us a choice, we can choose to love Him or we go to hell. I know it's a bitter pill to swallow, but what do you think Jesus died on the cross for, if not to try and save as many as possible from going to hell?

Reply to this Admin