The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website

Film Reviews

Vice Documentary Swansea Love Story Reviewed
antoinette fernandez , January 5th, 2010 12:49

New Vice documentary Swansea love Story is co-directed by Leo Leigh (son of Mike Leigh) and Andy Capper where drugs are the main love interest, says Antoinette Fernandez

Add your comment »

Over a period of six months filming Swansea’s drug-addicted youth, Leo Leigh (son of British auteur, Mike) and Andy Capper, UK Editor of Vice, have managed to discover some intriguing characters. Notably, Amy and Cornelius, a pair of habitual heroin users with a penchant for street drinking who provide the basis for the film's love story. However it is hard to get past their appalling biography and the vicious circle that has become their existence, and really appreciate that there is a romance of sorts going on. Our first introduction to them is a conversation in which it feels like they are competing with each other as to who started taking drugs first. (The winning age being 11.) And then on to whose life is more traumatic. (Amy was homeless at 12, but Cornelius was dealing drugs with his father at 16.) If the viewer finds their sympathy levels low at this point then they should brace themselves for what is to come.

Swansea Love Story is primarily about the effects on those growing up in the aftermath of the Welsh city's decline in industry, as the opening titles state: "In the last four years the small South Wales city of Swansea registered a 180 percent increase of heroin users. Young people made up the bulk of the increase."

The filmmakers not only capture the lives of Swansea’s drug addicts and alcoholics but also seek opinions on the situation from the elderly and those - even by the standards of this documentary - too young to be hard drug users.

For some reason the filmmakers decide to visit what appears to be a Goth strip club, and interview some of the girls there, probably to highlight the lack of career options available for young women in Swansea. So far, so Vice. But the scene bears no real relevance to the rest of the film and comes over as an indulgent excuse to include a few scantily clad girls who otherwise wouldn't have featured.

There is an interesting scene when two young boys set out their views not just on the drug problem in their neighbourhood but also on immigration and race. Moments of humour (albeit of the dark variety) pop up like beacons amidst the bleakness of the film, providing some genuinely amusing moments. Andrew’s advice on how not to go cold turkey being of note. All of which combined with the few tales of those who have successfully managed to stop taking class-A drugs and appear to be getting their lives back, enable the viewer to emphasise with people who at first seem irrevocably estranged from society.

Leigh and Capper have done an admirable job of capturing their subjects in a suitably non-invasive and respectful manner. Obviously it's arguable that you need to see people using drugs and hear about how they use them in order to gain an understanding of their lives. But it does make for disturbing viewing, which is of course to be expected given its pedigree.

I can’t help but think that a film of this nature would have benefited from distancing itself from the Vice brand as the connection doesn’t initially inspire confidence that the film will attempt to expose and educate rather than exploit. In comparison Duane Hopkins’ Better Things, a fictional portrayal of the reality of disenfranchised youth in dead-end towns, is unrestrained by the conventions of documentary filmmaking, enabling it to portray a more useful sense of the anguish and hopelessness felt by people in this position.

Here, these harsh realities are just laid bare.

One teenager discusses the fact that she has been forced into prostitution at the age of 12 by a mother that she has slept with - a particularly lurid moment in which she describes her mother’s genitals. This simply shocks and alienates.

Music from the Dunvant Male Voice Choir, adds some gravitas by evoking a bygone Swansea when people's lives were just as hard but as yet unscarred by the effects of narcotics. The choir also emphasises the fact that underneath the images of drug abuse and tales of poverty there is an underlying message of hope and the importance of not ignoring the plight of the less fortunate.

As a local man states during a Welsh Defence League Rally, complete with Nazi saluting fascists that "Swansea . . . is a good town. As long as everybody gets on. If you don’t get on, well you can’t make it can you?"

If you love our features, news and reviews, please support what we do with a one-off or regular donation. Year-on-year, our corporate advertising is down by around 90% - a figure that threatens to sink The Quietus. Hit this link to find out more and keep on Black Sky Thinking.

Chris Etches
Jan 6, 2010 2:16pm

I will watch this film with interest, trying to balance the feelings of 'that is a fucking tough life' with 'I hate you Cunts, you have ruined my City, and have done terrible terrible things'. A really nice lad who went to the school my Mum works at was murdered so violently by some smack dealing Cunts I'm guessing from roughly the same part of Town as they are from) just while he was walking home from a club (a walk I had done myself countless times.)

Going back to Swansea breaks my heart these days, it is such a pretty place, but the City Centre has been ruined, the people in charge have no idea how to save the City, and it's been this way for decades. Remember this is the City that had the World's first Passenger Rail system (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swansea_and_Mumbles_Railway) along the some of the Prettiest Coastline in the Country, which was torn down to extend a road by an extra lane. Now I'm not saying that having a quaint Railway system would somehow solve it's problems (thought the extra Tourist Cash would help), but it might have done a little to raise the levels of hope and pride in the City more than yet another empty Shopping Centre (Swansea Council is addicted to building new shopping centres and cinemas, even though there aren't enough shops to go in them.)

Anyways I could go on all day about this, but I shan't.

ChrisErrorx

Reply to this Admin

Chris Etches
Jan 6, 2010 2:18pm

working wiki link [as I can't edit posts]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swansea_and_Mumbles_Railway

Reply to this Admin

John Doran
Jan 6, 2010 2:59pm

In reply to Chris Etches:

I have similar feelings about St Helens and Hull to be honest.

Reply to this Admin

jelly
Jan 7, 2010 12:09am

I saw this at the ICA and can't believe the cold hearted attitude of the reviewer. I cried at least five times. Its a wonderful film with real compassion. I suggest the reviewer look that last word up in the dictionary. I thought the quietus ws better than this.

Reply to this Admin


Feb 3, 2010 3:08pm

In reply to Chris Etches:

do you know where I can find the lyrics of the song "Don't do drugs" that the little girl sings as well as the lyrics from the choir's song?

Please

Reply to this Admin

freddy
Feb 19, 2010 12:14am

I agree. This film is very poorly constructed, the editing doesn't make real sense. It is has almost no development, and the Vice stamp (or VBS) is probably making it taste even worst. Of course, if you cry when poor people complain about their sad life.. you might like this one, but to me there is quite a way to go before you can call that a film. For exemple, i like to think that the film makers have ideas of what they want to say, and it has to be more than drugs-shit-shock.

Reply to this Admin

nye
Feb 19, 2010 1:07pm

This is a good film. Shame people don't have the imagination to get past the usual anti-Vice, hipster bashing stuff. This was very different to other things I've seen on VBS which, in any case, is a very broad church.

Reply to this Admin


Feb 23, 2010 8:56pm

fukin shockin

Reply to this Admin

squeaky
Mar 3, 2010 12:46am

In reply to freddy :

"if you cry when poor people complain about their sad life.. you might like this one".

So cold hearted. Also, learn to spell the word "example".

Reply to this Admin

Steve
Mar 11, 2010 8:00pm

In reply to :

was wondering if you found out where you can find that song, "don't do drugs"

Reply to this Admin

Pam Nielsen
Mar 19, 2012 12:16am

Is there any follow-up on the main characters?

Reply to this Admin

Kim
Jul 21, 2013 4:10pm

Appauling review. Did you even watch it?

The girl in question, was forced into prostiution when she was 14, not 12. She made reference to having sex with her mother after a massive cider binge while she was accusing her boyfriend of doing the same, in anger.

ONE guy in the film kicked heroin. No one else did.

It is a well made documentary that will resonate with anybody that has had the misfortune to see addiction first hand.

Stop reviewing films. You are shite at it.

Reply to this Admin

ivano
Mar 20, 2015 10:52am

In reply to :

Hi, did you find the song???

Reply to this Admin

Andy
Dec 19, 2016 2:03pm

This documentary was very interesting as are all Vice Essential docs. Does anyone know the status of Amy and Cornelius? Wish there was a follow up

Reply to this Admin