The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website

Tome On The Range

Renegade: The Life and Tales of Mark E Smith reviewed
The Quietus , April 28th, 2008 13:29

John Doran reviews the long-awaited self portrait from Mark E Smith, and finds as much belly laughter as bile

Renegade: The Lives And Tales Of Mark E. Smith Mark E. Smith with Austen Collings Penguin/Viking

By John Doran

As a consumer you always receive Mark E. Smith through a filter. Sometimes it is a filter of his own design " psychic precognition, jumbled thoughts, paranoia and raving poetry obfuscated by the slur of the daytime drinker. And if not this self-created shield, then it’s via the never-ending stream of music journalists who (probably quite rightly) see an interview with him as being an essential part of their career. Even previous books have served to muddy the waters. It is true that Mick Middles penned the semi-autobiographical tome The Fall with his nibs, but this was more inscrutable than the lyrics from Grotesque " bizarrely, by the time you’ve turned the last page you realise you know more about Smith’s mam (and Middles) than you do about the subject. When I interviewed Smith two years ago in the Malmaison Hotel under the shadow of Manchester’s Piccadilly Station he sarcastically congratulated me on finishing it: “You have my commiserations. I couldn’t get past page 100. It’s not about me is it? It’s about Mick. That’s typical of someone from Stockport.” Then he cackled profusely.

The thing is, the real story has always been there for those willing to look for it, by rummaging through old and yellowing cuttings from the NME, reading lyrics that work like cryptic crossword clues (“To Nk Roachment: Yarbles”: Encroachment " bollocks to that; Hex Enduction Hour a sixty minute long album designed as a spell to end a period of bad luck), the fan site that all others should be judged against, the great sleeve notes by Daryl Easlea that came as part of the Sanctuary reissues. It is ironic that in this respect Smith is like his old sparring partner Morrissey: he tells you nothing but shows you everything. You just have to put a bit of effort in yourself.

That’s not to say that Renegade tells you all you want to know about Smith " just what he thinks is right that you know about him. Celebrity culture and gossip is just one of approximately 15,673 subjects that he is scathing about in this hilarious and bracing read. He lays the blame squarely at the door of three people: David Frost, Lloyd Grossman and Madonna. George Best, however, gets a free pass. He is one of the members of the long and hard to fathom list of people Smith likes or respects, alongside Dr Carl from Neighbours, Pete Waterman, Sam Fox, The Chuckle Brothers, and Louise Redknapp. He is enjoyably contrarian to a fault, even going as far as telling us how The Glitter Band were more influential than the Sex Pistols.

If the book has a fault (and it’s debatable that it does) it is that Smith is predictably bitter about the ex-members of his group. The book opens with Ben Pritchard, Steve Trafford and Spencer Birtwistle abandoning Smith and “The Wife” Elena in the Phoenix desert, and even with his spin on events, you come away feeling pleased you’re not in his band. (Well, not yet anyway " at fifty ex-members and constantly rising, if you plot a graph forward into the future by 2038 everyone still alive will have been in The Fall.) The antipathy he feels for these people makes for uncomfortable reading but even then he manages to temper this with withering wit from time to time: “They came. They saw. They fucked off.” The comparison of leaving his band to developing post-traumatic stress disorder is particularly good, Smith saying the musicians act as if “they’ve been to Vietnam or had a particularly fraught space excursion”.

This said, Renegade is a superb autobiography, probably one of the funniest books written about music. Despite the self-aggrandising and incomplete nature of Smith’s tale, it makes for a genuinely brilliant snapshot of one of the last English eccentrics in public life. It starts with the first of many hyper-real anecdotes that presents Smith’s gift for finding the arcane, the mystical, the lurid and the terrifying in everyday life. He talks about sitting with Stan “the pigeon guy” in the back garden next door to his childhood home in Prestwich, Greater Manchester. Stan, a teddy boy, employed carrier pigeons to send romantic billet-doux to his girlfriends who lived in Blackpool. If he was feeling particularly amorous he would despatch four birds so at least two would get through: “The other two would have been shot down by air rifle.”

The clues you might try to use to decipher Smith’s lyrics are few and far between, but casually strewn around. The ’Psycho Mafia’ was a “melting pot” of a teenage gang that he was part of; ’Repetition’ was actually influenced by the inmates at the local psychiatric institution; ’Fiery Jack’ is about the heavy drinkers of Manchester town: “Hard livers with hard livers. Faces like unmade beds.”

His disdain for people who resort to cliché or don’t or won’t think for themselves seethes off the pages. For example, it’s instructive after years of hearing people like Paul Morley and the late Anthony Wilson mythologize the Sex Pistols gig at the Lesser Free Trade Hall in Manchester to hear Smith’s take on it: “I thought, my lot are not as bad as that. We’re better. We just need a drummer.” And with that it was on.

The best bits are (presumably) diary extracts, scraps of lyrics, disjointed notes from crumpled bits of paper, all typed out into a stream of consciousness style narrative that comes across like a cross between TS Elliot, James Joyce, Bernard Manning and Jeffrey Barnard: “I hope to be an afternoon amnesiac . . . The dead remain piled: their mouths agape . . . The hanging room in The Ostrich. Don’t go in there. There’s a reason why it’s always empty. No one goes in there. Well, only those that don’t know . . .”

And there’s even the tongue in cheek exclusive that no one was expecting: “If anyone says to me that I’ve got a problem with the drink, I tell them I do have a problem " like where to get it after eleven o’clock. I’ve stopped drinking anyway " stopped half an hour ago.”

This is genuinely one of those rare rock autobiographies that will cause people who care nothing for the music at all and die-hard fans alike to revel in its pomposity-bursting, hilarious, grimily poetic brilliance. Mark E Smith: "I've seen too many groups go down in the name of democracy"

If you love our features, news and reviews, please support what we do with a one-off or regular donation. Year-on-year, our corporate advertising is down by around 90% - a figure that threatens to sink The Quietus. Hit this link to find out more and keep on Black Sky Thinking.

B'dum B'dum
Apr 28, 2008 3:03pm

"TS Elliot, James Joyce, Bernard Manning and Jeffrey Barnard"-that sounds like a brilliantly terrible mixture.

Reply to this Admin

cockney wag
Apr 28, 2008 4:40pm

what a dispiriting read from the self mythologising old troll. I wonder if the ex members he lies and libels in the book will see him in court?

Reply to this Admin

Luke Turner
Apr 28, 2008 4:45pm

Are you a bitter ex-member, Cockney Wag? Every time we put up a bit of content about them you're here in minutes, having a moan...

Reply to this Admin

cockney wag
Apr 28, 2008 5:05pm

i'm actually a fan of the band but the unquestioning critical stance on the singer is a tad annoying.

Reply to this Admin

NYC Plastic Paddy Cockney
Apr 28, 2008 5:14pm

Renegade: as is to music as
"Full Time: the Secret Life of Tony Cascarino" is to football.

So refreashing to hear unfiltered what someone thinks and does in the "Public" eye. No PC !No Compromise! No contenders. Buy the book.

Reply to this Admin

cockney wag
Apr 28, 2008 5:25pm

he's edited out his racist jokes and Tory voting

Reply to this Admin

John Doran
Apr 28, 2008 5:33pm

His Tory voting is covered in the chapter called 'The Wife'.

What racist jokes? Seriously, I've never even heard of this . . .

Reply to this Admin

B'dum B'dum
Apr 28, 2008 5:50pm

the wife? which wife?

NYC... that tony cascarino book looks fantastic.

Reply to this Admin

May 3, 2008 7:09pm

Why is it hard to fathom why he would like George Best? One would be hard pressed to find a person who knew him who didn't like him.

Reply to this Admin

baby jebus
May 26, 2008 6:58pm

Having just read it, I really have to say you gave him one hell of a soft ride, JD. Anyone who comes to this book without knowing at least some of MES's backstory is going to wonder why some nutcase with a consistent record of failure and marginal fame at best is rambling on about some perceived insult made by the NME in 1982. As my own Prestwich bud reckons, no one in his own little world ever dares to tell him he's an unconscionable cunt of little importance, so when he's dismissed or ignored by the 99.9 % of the population that has better things to do than care about his work, he takes it personally. In fact the person he most reminds me of is Julie Burchill, another semi-educated, undeniably bright working class autodidact, who knows something and thinks it's everything. Neither of them can construct an argument that will stand the slightest scrutiny, but their intuitive ability to uncover a certain unexpected truth is impressive, and often mistaken for wisdom. His alleged work ethic is interesting too- is he expressing guilt at having lucked out at not having to join the proles. Of course it may just be that he thinks he has to work to deserve a drink...
I have to recommend this book though. It's brilliant. Smith is just hilarious, with his elegantly idiotic assertions and strange beliefs and fantastical stories (The drunken Orange giant emerging from The Ostrich armed with a bread knife and set on assassinating the Pope, holding a mass to thousands in the nearby park, and being brought down by a gaggle of cardinals is more MES than the man himself could invent, while his guileless moan about his farcical face to face with Michael Bracewell is a scream). The new album is top too. Just as long as I never have to meet or work or deal with him, he's fine with me. I could do without the annoying and juvenile snippets myself though.
Has he started moaning about Austin Collings's impressive ghostwriting job yet?

Reply to this Admin