The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website


The Rebirth of Disco
Simon Price , April 9th, 2008 13:27

Add your comment »

"Disco will never be over. It will always live in our minds and hearts. Something like this, that was this big, and this important, and this great, will never die. Oh, for a few years - maybe many years - it'll be considered passé and ridiculous. It will be misrepresented and caricatured and sneered at, or - worse - completely ignored. People will laugh about John Travolta, Olivia Newton-John, white polyester suits and platform shoes and people going like this [strikes disco pose]. But we had nothing to do with those things and still loved disco. Those who didn't understand will never understand: disco was much more, and much better, than all that. Disco was too great, and too much fun, to be gone forever! It's got to come back someday. I just hope it will be in our own lifetimes."

This speech from actor Matt Keeslar, a jarringly inspirational moment in Whit Stillman's otherwise disastrously dull Last Days Of Disco (killer soundtrack album notwithstanding), might be coming true at last. It's been a long wait.

Old battle scars don't heal easily, and few music wars have been as bloody or as enduringly divisive as that between rock and disco. The notorious Comiskey Park incident in which radio jocks Garry Meier and Steve Dahl - whipping up thinly-veiled homophobic and racist sentiment - organised a public blowing-up of disco records in a Chicago baseball stadium, was merely the most famous flashpoint of the 'Disco Sucks' campaign of 1979. (And, of course, was inadvertently a powerful endorsement for the disco movement: as the old proverb goes, "By their enemies shall ye know them".)

"By their enemies shall ye know them" - a modern news report on the Comiskey Park incident

Three decades later, the signs are that the stigma attached to disco has finally ebbed away. Two excellent mix albums have pointed the way back to the source: Ellboy, the latest (and finest) from International Deejay Gigolos prime mover DJ Hell, and Bob Sinclar Live At The Playboy Mansion (the French have always had a special relationship with disco, ever since Sheila & B Devotion's 'Spacer' provided one of the genre's greatest moments).

Meanwhile, in New York City, disco's spiritual home, the metaphorical mirrorballs are spinning once again. The rise of the Scissor Sisters from underground art-fag rumour to global pop phenomenon did a lot to shake up inhibitions and loosen uptight arses. In their wake come, among others, Hercules & Love Affair (with Antony Hegarty essentially doing for them what Alison Moyet did for Vince Clarke in Yazoo), and their similarly-named city-mates Heloise & The Savoir Faire (imagine Frankie Goes To Hollywood fronted by a young Stevie Nicks).

And, back in the UK, some of the sharper thinkers in the indie sector are ahead of the curve. With their Erol Alkan-produced second album Couples, The Long Blondes have amplified their already-latent disco tendencies to stunning effect, while Franz Ferdinand (surely already pretty disco themselves) toyed with the idea of having their third album produced by Brian Higgins' Xenomania, the team responsible for Girls Aloud's finest moments, among others.

During the disco era itself, some of the most enthusiastic wearers of 'Disco Sucks' badges were the doltish and reactionary wing of the punks. The truth is that disco and punk - both brilliantly populist, and brilliantly pop responses to the hippy hegemony - were never natural enemies, as Debbie Harry, one of the few punks to understand the potential of disco, recognised on 'Heart Of Glass' and 'Atomic'. It's surely no coincidence that she turns up as guest vocalist three times on Heloise & The Savoir Faire's debut album.

One thing that Allan Jones and Jussi Kantonen's excellent disco history Saturday Night Forever makes abundantly clear is that disco's importance was social as much as musical. If disco had only consisted of the exclusive, elitist Byzantine decadence of Studio 54 (which by all accounts, including Anthony Haden-Guest's eyebrow-raising The Last Party, amounted to Caligula with a four-to-the-floor backbeat) it would still have been a fascinating curio which left some exhilarating music behind. But it was far more than that: disco was nothing less than a cultural revolution.

Rockers in the 50s had their hops, and the mods in the 60s had their underground sweatboxes, but for most people in smalltown Britain and America prior to disco, the phrase 'night club' meant somewhere self-consciously faux-classy where you sported your special-occasion eveningwear, drank overpriced white wine, ate chicken in a basket and made stilted attempts at seduction to the sounds of light jazz and lounge music. Disco changed everything. For the first time, straight white people, taking their cue from the black, latino and gay subcultures, were partying in significant numbers. The spirit, borrowed by Chic ("these are the good times") from Roxy Music ("the good life isn't won by degrees"), was at the same time democratic and openly aspirational: the high life, on a Saturday night at least, is for everyone.

One of the prime rockist critiques of disco was that it somehow wasn't 'real' music. Indeed, given that replicating many of the best disco records onstage would require balancing the sound of a Moog sequencer with a 24-piece string section, 'cutting it live' was impractical. Some bands, the extraordinary Chic for example (see Daryl Easlea's Everybody Dance: Chic And The Politics Of Disco for a full account of their importance), could cut it live and, as you'll be aware if you've been fortunate enough to catch Nile Rodgers' touring band, still can. But "cutting it live" is a hippy quality-gauge (you can almost feel the ghost of Whispering Bob Harris looking over your shoulder), which completely misses the point of music which was created specifically for the radio and the dancefloor.

Chic play 'Le Freak' live in 1978

With the passage of time, disco has become viewed by the more enlightened critics - Garry Mulholland's polemic This Is Uncool: The 500 Greatest Singles Since Punk And Disco being a superb example - as a Year Zero on a par with that of punk. At the time, however, the post-punkers' response to disco was a belated and qualified one. Whether it was ACR and PiL in the UK, or Tom Tom Club and ESG in the States, it invariably involved engaging with funk rather than disco per se (funk bearing roughly the same relationship to disco that rock does to pop: its more earnest, more serious, more highbrow older brother). All very well, but nothing to make you wanna do spins or lose yourself in the dizziness of the moment. Only Duran Duran fessed up to fantasising about fusing the Sex Pistols with Chic, and who ever took them seriously?

A decade later, the Madchester craze may have lured white rock demographic back onto the dancefloor in significant numbers, but the indie-dance crossover was all about connecting with techno (which, like funk, also carried a certain chin-strokey respectability). For twenty years, the word 'disco' was inseparable from wacky stag nights and student rag weeks, and the comedy trappings of afro wigs, white waistcoats and flares " essentially everything predicted by the speaker in Stillman's film.

The mood started to change in the mid-90s, and it took the French, unencumbered by the weight of rockist gravitas, to make it happen. The likes of Daft Punk, Cassius, Etienne de Crecy and countless lesser-known disco-house pioneers began to turn dancefloors back into somewhere you could actually throw some moves, not just monkey-dance or nod your head.

Goldfrapp acknowledged the French connection in 2005, making a respectful nod towards Cerrone's apocalyptic, millenarian 1977 epic 'Supernature', naming their third album after it, and playing it directly before stage-time for a whole tour.

By 2008, the slow-crashing wave has rippled back to New York, London, Berlin and beyond, and Hell, Hercules and Heloise, Bob and the Blondes, Franz Ferdinand and many others are, in their individual ways, proving that it's possible to exhibit a love of disco without having anything whatsoever to do with "John Travolta, Olivia Newton-John, white polyester suits and platform shoes and people going like this".

Getting taken seriously while doing it is another matter. But life's too short to worry about that.

Disco makes it to the British regions

If you love our features, news and reviews, please support what we do with a one-off or regular donation. Year-on-year, our corporate advertising is down by around 90% - a figure that threatens to sink The Quietus. Hit this link to find out more and keep on Black Sky Thinking.

Apr 16, 2008 2:48pm

Brillaint piece, Simon.

Reply to this Admin

Mark Pringle
Apr 16, 2008 5:01pm

Great piece, with one big caveat: you don't talk about where disco's at today in its purest form. It's fine to name-check all the rock bands that have nodded in disco's direction, but what of people playing disco records on dancefloors? There's a wonderful, burgeoning semi-underground disco club scene that has been gathering up converts, gay and straight, in every city in the land for well over a decade. Bill Brewster & Frank Broughton (writers of Last Night A DJ Saved My Life) have been throwing Low Life parties in London, combining House and that disco/funk/eclectic mishmash known as Balearic, for ten years (maybe longer). Horsemeat Disco rock gay/polysexual crowds regularly in London's answer to Christopher Street, Vauxhall. And many, many more. It ain't always about boys with guitars, y'know.

Reply to this Admin

Baseball » The Rebirth of Disco
Apr 9, 2008 3:31pm

[...] The Quietus wrote an interesting post today on The Rebirth of DiscoHere’s a quick excerpt … lowing-up of disco records in a Chicago baseball stadium, was merely the most famous flashpoint of the ‘D isco Sucks’ campaign of 1979…. [...]

Reply to this Admin

Apr 9, 2008 7:01pm

Great stuff, Simon.

That fault line between disco and funk was rather passé by the late '70s when the two increasingly merged. Indeed, the era when the Disco Sucks movement was at its height coincided with the most effective fusion between the two, roughly the era1978-83.

Recently I posted a disco-funk mix on my blog. One comment questioned whether KC & the Sunshine Band had ripped off Jimmy 'Bo' Horne. Of course, they were label mates, and KC wrote Horne's hits. Chin-stroking funksters would have no beef with Horne, one expects, while KC & the Sunshine Band had credibility only among the disco crowd (and people who appreciate great pop), to make a sweeping statement.

Reply to this Admin

Apr 16, 2008 11:41pm

I stopped reading about half way down but Antony Hegarty DOES look like Alison Moyet. Well done.

Reply to this Admin

Apr 17, 2008 8:29pm

Mark - on the angle of disco never having gone away, you could easily pick out David Mancuso, who's loft party celebrated its 38th birthday party this year. It is an astounding night, and actually feels like it is little changed since it began.

If you start to stretch the recent disco revival the piece might never end - Lindstrom, Prins Thomas and the whole Space disco crew, WhateverWeWantRecords - there is a lot of disco stuff been picking up over the past three years again, and a lot that has alway been.

Reply to this Admin

Mark Pringle
Apr 18, 2008 10:25am

dglh, you're right on all points, though I really didn't enjoy the one Loft party I went to: far too reverential, what with all that clapping between tunes, and an audiophile soundsystem that may have sounded gorgeous but didn't deliver the kick in the solar plexus that this old geezer needs to start dancing like your drunk uncle at a wedding.

Reply to this Admin

loofy mcginty
Jul 11, 2008 1:32pm

great piece. its the lack of context and history that makes a lot of (excuses for) music 'journalism' so dull but this provides it excellent-ly. and i now have at least 4 interesting-sounding albums to check out... hope the quietus continues like this, it makes dull days at work almost a pleasure.

Reply to this Admin

Marcus O'Dair
Jul 21, 2008 4:21pm

Reply to this Admin

Marcus O'Dair
Jul 21, 2008 4:23pm

Sorry, that was spectacularly dumb misuse of the comment function. Maybe if I want to contact I should go to... er, contact.

Reply to this Admin

Jason Goldman
Jul 23, 2008 1:38am

Just to clarify the whole "whipping up racism and homophobia" misconceptions about the Comiskey Park Event that I've heard too otf-tend, the Disco Demolition Night was a backlash against the commercialism and all-encompassing takeover of disco. The DJs who started it were fired from an all-rock station after it switched to disco, and started a "Disco Sucks" backlash.

(from - "Harry Wayne Casey of KC and the Sunshine Band denounced it as a racist, homophobic attack on a positive, multicultural style of music.
Dahl and colleagues, who had been ordered not to discuss Disco Demolition on the air but did so anyway, shrugged off the rebukes, saying they had no ill will towards minorities or gays-they just thought the music and the lifestyle were lame." Seems to me that KC would have an impetus to keep the disco fad going.)

And Disco did suck. If it was all Cerrone's Supernature, there wouldn't have been a problem. However, it wasn't. It was seen as an instant money-making machine. If you had a hotel with a lobby, you started a "disco night." Dance Fever was on every night. In America as well, especially in the 70s, if a music did well it was on every radio station. People were voting for the music they liked, by blowing up the records they didn't like. Homophobia and Racism had nothing to do with it.

The fact that Prince came from Minneapolis, a 45 minute plane ride from Chicago, and many of the same fans of AC/DC would end up fans of his as well, would certainly dismiss any of these allegations.

Reply to this Admin

Mitchell P
Jul 29, 2008 12:52pm

Had the demolition not happened it may have evolved into a part of the culture the way salsa is to Latin people. The 70's was a dance era, when people knew how to do it. It should have lasted. As a cultured we should have embraced it and molded it without the violent protests that against it. We may have killed something good for the country and unifying. Imagine if we were to do anything similiar with "rap" music or "punk". People don't dance anymore. We are now the talky, chatty, drinking, stand around society. Dancin, that was behind it. I hope it can go mainstream again. Get people out and onto the floor.

Reply to this Admin

Matt Lindsay
Jul 10, 2010 6:45pm

Surely disco had an overt influence on the post-punk landscape beyond Duran Duran? Pil openly extolled the virtues of Donna Summer's I Feel Love (a quasimodo mutation apppears on thier debut platter). Simon Reynold's rip it up and start again shows how disco was an integral part of the post-punk/new pop aesthetic with everyone from Orange Juice , The Associates , Human League and ABC owing a debt to it.
Disco's earliest records, think Temptations' law Of the Land, Harold Melvin's Love I Lost and Eddie Kendricks' sublime Girl You Need a Change Of Mind WERE essentially funk/soul records played religiously in gay clubs.Not strictly intended for such purposes, djs clubgoers were very much active 'participants' in shaping the disco aesthetic . As the 70's progressed and disco became big business , it became deracinated from its' black/ gay synergy (Saturday Night Fever) and lost much its' erm soul lapsing into lurid gameshow music bombast. Simultaneously , drugs started to shape the spine of gay clubbing (rather than merely accompanying it) and hi-nrg's blanched-out repetition reflected this. This is why discophobia is so disingenuous and myopic. What many naysayers regard as a limited four-to the floor bland genre is actually one of infinite variety and far-reaching influence.

Reply to this Admin

Sep 13, 2011 12:27am

Specialists claim that mortgage loans help a lot of people to live their own way, because they are able to feel free to buy needed stuff. Moreover, different banks give credit loan for different classes of people.

Reply to this Admin