The Quietus - A new rock music and pop culture website

Black Sky Thinking

Vive La France! Lessons The UK Can Learn From Hollande's Election Victory
Joe Kennedy , May 10th, 2012 11:33

Hollande's victory for the French Socialist Party in the weekend's Presidential Elections provoked outpourings of emotion and solidarity of the sort rarely seen in the UK, says Joe Kennedy. Photograph thanks to Valerio Berdini

Add your comment »

The girl on the stanchion above us was only six or seven, but remained in her vantage point for well over two hours, waving a Left Front flag with undiminishing enthusiasm. At the foot of the lamp post, her parents were peering through the crowds towards the giant screen on the opposite side of the vast Place de la Bastille. It was almost one in the morning before Francois Hollande, France's incoming Socialist president, arrived from his provincial constituency to address the half a million or so who had been assembling since early evening.

By that point, many in his audience were tired and emotional to varying degrees, having smothered the pavements around the Colonne de Juillet with empty beer bottles and thickened the air with hash smoke. Indeed, aspects of what was taking place bore striking similarities to a large rave. A number of warm-up speakers and performers - including former presidential candidate Ségolène Royal, ex-PM Lionel Jospin and a trio of Berber feminists – provoked increasingly intense emotional responses ahead of the coming of the highly-anticipated headline act. Meanwhile, strobes flickered across the heads of those gathered, and teenagers from the banlieues flew the colours of Algeria or the Côte d'Ivoire alongside those of France and various left-wing groups.

For the British observer, both unavoidable and unfamiliar was that Nicolas Sarkozy's defeat had been responded to in a way so demonstratively public. Although the Parti Socialiste had made provisions for a celebration in the event of victory, the nature of what was happening at the Bastille resembled a spontaneous display of feeling far more than it did a stage-managed political rally. Most significantly, though, the feeling in question amounted to a desire to mark the striking of a blow for the French and European left in a fashion which disestablished the boundaries between the private individual and the collective. This wasn't simply an exuberant reaction to the overthrow of an increasingly ludicrous leader: it was representative of a commitment to a particular way of experiencing public space which is written into socialism's DNA.

Looking at the hundreds of young people of diverse ethnic and religious background chanting and setting off flares on the Colonne, it was difficult not to reflect on the improbability of such a scene taking place in modern Britain. We struggle nowadays to produce the kind of broad-church leftism displayed in Paris, where old-fashioned trade unionists embraced the company of young families, student radicals and kids from the city's sink estates. In theory, ideologically-driven cuts, a government which bends without fail to the will of the City and of media conglomerates, the masquerading of driven Machiavellians like Boris Johnson as matey 'buffoons' and surface-to-air missiles on tower block roofs constitute a cumulative weight of wrongness sufficient to bring such attitudes into being. In practice, however, oppositional politics in this country are notable either for their absence or their partiality.

There's dissent here, of course, but it tends to be issue-specific or divisive. Occupy drew sympathy from people who would never in a million years have participated in it, but it also struck many as somewhat preening and vanguardist. The anti-cuts movement is impressively inclusive, but tends to articulate its demands in negative terms: generally speaking, it's more against austerity than for systemic change. A significant number of Scots have responded to the misgoverning of the UK by turning towards a nationalist party who favour washing their hands of what are regarded as English problems. Meanwhile, last year's riots were spurred by resentments which were political in essence but manifested themselves in nihilistic violence and spectacles of aggression, angering huge numbers of those who have lost most in David Cameron's extension of the neoliberal experiment.

That the immediate response to Hollande's victory should resemble one of Britain's greatest twentieth-century contributions to the category of collective experience is telling. Clichéd as it sounds, rave picked up the baton of responsibility for producing a sense of shared popular purpose from both football, which was undergoing quasi-privatisation from the late 1980s onwards, and left politics, which had been damaged by Thatcherism, the apparent victory of capitalist ideology in the Cold War, and (to a certain extent) by its own sectarianism. Parties in warehouses or Surrey woodlands were driven at least in part by the need to maintain the possibility of collective experience in the face of the damage sustained by its traditional vehicles. One saw this play for continuity at the time of the Criminal Justice Bill, which was challenged in a way that clearly demonstrated how rave had absorbed and repurposed some of the energies of more explicitly political movements. But something has shifted. Almost imperceptibly, rave segued into festival culture. And with their meaning having altered considerably during the interim years, like 'uni' and 'traveling', any broader social purpose that was once ascribed to festivals has been obscured by the rhetoric of 'having an experience', which fosters one's self-regard as an autonomous individual.

The fact that the victory of a moderate leftist such as Hollande provoked such joy can be read variously. Pragmatists will say that resentment at Sarkozy was the driving force; pessimists might point out that the European left has been weakened to such an extent over the last ten years that its supporters have become like the proverbial football fans whose club is so woeful that a throw-in becomes cause for cheer. Against this, it needs to be remembered that Hollande's share of the second round of polling included as many as five million votes transferred from parties and groupings such as Jean-Luc Mélenchon's appealingly anti-corporate Left Front and smaller radical organisations. This means that his mandate rests, to some extent, on those with an active antipathy to relentless privatisation and vandalistic, market-appeasing austerity measures. It also demonstrates that socialism has not, as some would still try and have you believe, become utterly divorced from a popular base.

Bearing this in mind, the real lesson for depressed Britain lies in the togetherness visible in the celebration of the Parti socialiste's win. This summer will give us plenty of 'public' events which affirm the status quo: there's the Jubilee, with the inevitable performatively communitarian tea parties, as well as the Olympics (brought to you by some beer company, some mobile phone company, and several defence contractors). Like the festivals (of which there will be no shortage this summer either), these simulate authentic collective experience while offering no space in which to question dominant political narratives or produce new ones. It would undoubtedly be fantastic to see kids aloft on their parents' shoulders in Trafalgar Square celebrating not the longevity of an unelected ruler but the coming to power of a party who offered a more equitable political vision than those currently on offer. If this is to happen, however, it's essential that a reassessment of the meaning and value of public experience takes place sooner rather than later.

Photo by Valerio Berdini

If you love our features, news and reviews, please support what we do with a one-off or regular donation. Year-on-year, our corporate advertising is down by around 90% - a figure that threatens to sink The Quietus. Hit this link to find out more and keep on Black Sky Thinking.


May 11, 2012 11:18am

Good piece, and good news for France. But isn’t that a slightly abstract lesson for the UK to learn? French political culture has always been more voluble and demonstrative across the spectrum - including their immigrant-obsessed far-right. Here, outside of a steady, much tutted-at protest culture, we’ve tended to keep a poker face then have sudden outbursts like the Poll Tax riots. If the Labour Party became the Labour Party again now I’m convinced they’d clean up. But how do we make that happen?

Reply to this Admin


May 11, 2012 7:16pm

I'll give the French a year before the regret sets in...

Reply to this Admin

Chal Ravens
May 12, 2012 4:09pm

That paragraph on rave is excellent.

Reply to this Admin


May 12, 2012 7:40pm

In the first round of voting, Le Pen's National Front won nearly 20% of the vote. Do you really envy the French their political culture? And a fairly large proportion seemed to think that Communism is the answer. The French can keep their liking for extremists, thanks.

Reply to this Admin

Raveknave
May 14, 2012 7:27am

In reply to :

Er... Melanchon was the designated Communist Party candidate but is not a communist per se. He offered a radical manifesto against the status quo which had some appealing elements to it, not necessarily an extremist. And Marine Le Pen could have done a lot better after making her party seem more normal and a viable alternative to the flash right offered by Sarkozy. The French are infinitely
more politically engaged than the British, because sometimes people get the candidates that speak for them and the issues that matter to them. Dismissing them out of hand for being 'extremists' without looking at the situation in depth is a bit arrogant isn't it?

Reply to this Admin